Sit/Start Week 25: Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups From 9/24 – 9/30

Here's a giant table of every starting pitcher matchup for Week 25, telling you which pitchers should get in your lineup or stick on your bench.

Every Sunday here at Pitcher List, I review all expected starting pitcher matchups for the week ahead. There are three labels: StartMaybe, and Sit. Outings marked with a Maybe are circumstantial and dependent on your needs in a standard 5×5 Wins 12-teamer, while the other two are self-explanatory. Feel free to question my designations in the comments and we’ll dive into it together.

Here’s the massive table containing every Week 25 start from 9/24 – 9/30:

Note: These matchups are subject to change.

DateGameAway PitcherSit / StartHome PitcherSit / Start
9/24LAD vs ARIClayton KershawStartRobbie RayStart
9/24BAL vs BOSDylan BundySitNathan EovaldiStart
9/24PIT vs CHCJameson TaillonStartCole HamelsStart
9/24CLE vs CHWCorey KluberStartDylan CoveySit
9/24PHI vs COLZach EflinSitTyler AndersonMaybe
9/24TEX vs LAAAdrian SampsonSitFelix PenaStart
9/24OAK vs SEADaniel MengdenSitJames PaxtonStart
9/24SDP vs SFGBryan MitchellSitDerek HollandStart
9/24MIL vs STLChase AndersonSitJack FlahertyStart
9/24NYY vs TBRLuis SeverinoStartDiego CastilloSit
9/24HOU vs TORDallas KeuchelStartMarco EstradaSit
9/24MIA vs WSHSandy AlcantaraStartStephen StrasburgStart
9/25LAD vs ARIWalker BuehlerStartMatt KochSit
9/25BAL vs BOSBullpenSitDavid PriceStart
9/25PIT vs CHCChris ArcherMaybeMike MontgomerySit
9/25CLE vs CHWTrevor BauerStartJames ShieldsSit
9/25KCR vs CINEric SkoglundSitMatt HarveyMaybe
9/25PHI vs COLVince VelasquezSitJon GrayStart
9/25TEX vs LAAYovani GallardoSitMatt ShoemakerMaybe
9/25DET vs MINSpencer TurnbullSitKohl StewartSit
9/25ATL vs NYMTouki ToussaintStartNoah SyndergaardStart
9/25OAK vs SEABrett AndersonSitMike LeakeSit
9/25SDP vs SFGRobbie ErlinSitChris StrattonMaybe
9/25MIL vs STLGio GonzalezMaybeAustin GomberMaybe
9/25NYY vs TBRMasahiro TanakaStartBullpenSit
9/25HOU vs TORJosh JamesStartSam GaviglioSit
9/25MIA vs WSHJeff BrighamSitMax ScherzerStart
9/26LAD vs ARIRoss StriplingStartZack GreinkeStart
9/26BAL vs BOSYefry RamirezSitChris SaleStart
9/26PIT vs CHCIvan NovaSitJose QuintanaStart
9/26CLE vs CHWJosh TomlinSit???Sit
9/26KCR vs CINHeath FillmyerSitCody ReedMaybe
9/26PHI vs COLNick PivettaSitGerman MarquezStart
9/26TEX vs LAAYohander MendezSitAndrew HeaneyStart
9/26DET vs MINMatthew BoydStartJake OdorizziMaybe
9/26ATL vs NYMSean NewcombSitJacob DegromStart
9/26OAK vs SEAEdwin JacksonMaybeFelix HernandezSit
9/26SDP vs SFGEric LauerSitMadison BumgarnerStart
9/26MIL vs STLJhoulys ChacinMaybeJohn GantSit
9/26NYY vs TBRCC SabathiaMaybeBullpenSit
9/26HOU vs TORGerrit ColeStartSean-Reid FoleySit
9/26MIA vs WSHWei-Yin ChenMaybeTanner RoarkMaybe
9/27HOU vs BALJustin VerlanderStartDavid HessSit
9/27PIT vs CHCTrevor WilliamsMaybeJon LesterStart
9/27PHI vs COLJake ArrietaSitAntonio SenzatelaSit
9/27CLE vs KCRMike ClevingerStartJorge LopezSit
9/27DET vs MINFrancisco LirianoSitStephen GonsalvesSit
9/27ATL vs NYMJulio TeheranMaybeJason VargasSit
9/27TEX vs SEAMike MinorStartMarco GonzalesMaybe
9/27NYY vs TBRLance LynnSitTyler GlasnowMaybe
9/28HOU vs BALFramber ValdezStartBullpenSit
9/28NYY vs BOSJ.A. HappStartRick PorcelloMaybe
9/28STL vs CHCAdam WainwrightSitKyle HendricksStart
9/28PIT vs CINNick Kingham?SitLuis CastilloStart
9/28WSH vs COLJoe RossSitKyle FreelandStart
9/28CLE vs KCRAdam PlutkoSitIan KennedySit
9/28OAK vs LAAMike FiersMaybeJaime BarriaSit
9/28DET vs MILJordan ZimmermannSitZach DaviesMaybe
9/28CHW vs MINReynaldo LopezStartJose BerriosStart
9/28CHW vs MINLucas GiolitoMaybeChase-De JongSit
9/28MIA vs NYMJose UrenaStartCorey OswaltSit
9/28ATL vs PHIKevin GausmanStartAaron NolaStart
9/28ARI vs SDPPatrick CorbinStartJacob NixSit
9/28TEX vs SEAMartin PerezSitWade LeBlancMaybe
9/28LAD vs SFGRich HillStartDereck RodriguezMaybe
9/28TOR vs TBRThomas PannoneSitBullpenSit
9/29HOU vs BALCharlie MortonStartDylan BundySit
9/29NYY vs BOSLuis SeverinoMaybeEduardo RodriguezMaybe
9/29STL vs CHCMiles MikolasStartCole HamelsStart
9/29PIT vs CINJameson TaillonStartAnthony DesclafaniSit
9/29WSH vs COLErick FeddeSitTyler AndersonSit
9/29CLE vs KCRCorey KluberStartJakob JunisSit
9/29OAK vs LAATrevor CahillSitTyler SkaggsSit
9/29DET vs MILDaniel NorrisSitWade MileyStart
9/29CHW vs MINCarlos RodonStartKyle GibsonStart
9/29MIA vs NYMTrevor RichardsMaybeSteven MatzStart
9/29ATL vs PHIMike FoltynewiczStartZach EflinSit
9/29ARI vs SDPZack GodleyMaybeJoey LucchesiStart
9/29TEX vs SEAAdrian SampsonSitJames PaxtonStart
9/29LAD vs SFGHyun-Jin RyuStartAndrew SuarezSit
9/29TOR vs TBRRyan BoruckiSitBlake SnellStart
9/30HOU vs BALDallas KeuchelStartBullpenSit
9/30NYY vs BOSMasahiro Tanaka?MaybeNathan EovaldiMaybe
9/30STL vs CHCJack FlahertyStartMike MontgomerySit
9/30PIT vs CINChris ArcherMaybeMatt HarveyMaybe
9/30WSH vs COLStephen StrasburgStartJon GrayMaybe
9/30CLE vs KCRTrevor BauerStartBrad KellerSit
9/30OAK vs LAABrett AndersonSitFelix PenaSit
9/30DET vs MILSpencer TurnbullSitChase AndersonSit
9/30CHW vs MINDylan CoveySitKohl StewartSit
9/30MIA vs NYMSandy AlcantaraStartNoah SyndergaardStart
9/30ATL vs PHIAnibal SanchezStartVince VelasquezSit
9/30ARI vs SDPRobbie RayStartBryan MitchellSit
9/30TEX vs SEAYovani GallardoSitMike LeakeMaybe
9/30LAD vs SFGClayton KershawStartDerek HollandMaybe
9/30TOR vs TBRMarco EstradaSitBullpenSit

Nick Pollack

Founder of Pitcher List. Rotographs contributor. Worked with CBS Sports, Grantland, Washington Post, and SB Nation. Former pitching coach and Brandeis alum.

  • Avatar Peter says:

    Nick,

    I need to choose 6 of the following 8 options for this week.

    – Clevinger (KC)
    – Carrasco. (?)
    – Grienke (LAD)
    – Marquez (PHI)
    – Buehler (ARI)
    – Castillo (PIT)
    – F.Pena (TEX +)
    – Eovaldi (BAL +)

    + For Pena and Eovaldi, I can start them today and pick someone off of waivers tonight and get a second start. (i.e. Toussaint, Josh James, Montgomery, Alcantara) (some of these would have a chance of getting me a third start … but that’s difficult to count on)

    What do you think? Drop Carrasco? Is that crazy?

    • Nick Pollack Nick Pollack says:

      I’d drop Pena and maybe Greinke.

      I first wanted to say Carrasco, but him coming in after Bauer = great chance at a Win, and he could easily get 5+ innings.

      Pretty close between the two of them, though.

  • Avatar Rick says:

    Nick,
    Can you help me pick 4 of these 6 options (QS league)?
    1. Holland v. SD
    2. Sale v. NYY
    3. Bumgarner v. SD
    4. Greinke v. LAD
    5. Clevinger v. KC
    6. Toussant v. NYM

    You think Cleveland might shorten Clevinger’s start in prep for playoffs?
    Thanks.

    • Nick Pollack Nick Pollack says:

      Wow. Love all of these.

      Drop Holland and Toussaint. If you’re worried about the QS from Sale (he probably won’t get one as he won’t last six frames), then keep Toussaint.

      • Avatar Rick says:

        Thanks. Head spinning. I was pretty sure you’d prefer Holland over Bumgarner with both going against SD. I’m worried about that Dodger’s offense too. Tough calls.

  • Avatar Michael says:

    Why is Alcantara a double ‘START’? Did your opinion change about something? In your Two-Start Pitchers for Week 25 you had his starts under the ‘Questionable’ tier.

    • Nick Pollack Nick Pollack says:

      Good question. His first start against the Nationals could easily be a “Maybe”, but I essentially wanted to express that if you’re going for it, I ultimately think you’re okay going with Sandy in that first start and definitely against the Mets.

      In the Two-Start article, I’m often a little more conservative, if that makes sense. I guess I could just label that Nats start a “Maybe” and make things clearer.

  • Avatar tiger says:

    how would you rank these guys for this week in a pts league? thanks.
    sabathia,holland,stripling,stratton,godley,morton

  • Avatar Erli Zhou says:

    Can you rank the below starts in a standard points league(W/L matters):
    Touki Toussaint @ NYM
    Josh James @ TOR
    Matt Boyd @ MIN
    Kyle Gibson vs CHW
    Jose Urena @ NYM
    Trevor Richards @ NYM
    Thanks!

  • Account / Login
    >