Pitcher List’s Staff Consensus Top 300 Rankings – 2019

Pitcher List writers put together their consensus top 300 player rankings for 2019.

It’s time for some rankings! 19 of our writers sent in their personal top 300 rankings, and we’ve combined them all to give to you the consensus rankings for our site. Use these rankings to help create your own draft rankings, to help gauge trade value, and to see how players are valued by a large group of industry writers.

These rankings were made with head-to-head, standard 5×5 scoring, 12-team leagues in mind. These were also done prior to some of the most recent news, such as Bryce Harper signing with the Phillies.

 

Overall Top 300

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Mike TroutOF1.011100%
2Mookie BettsOF2.022100%
3Jose Ramirez2B, 3B3.135100%
4J.D. MartinezOF5.148100%
5Nolan Arenado3B5.4311100%
6Trea TurnerSS8.6416100%
7Max ScherzerSP8.7618100%
8Manny Machado3B, SS9.8627100%
9Christian YelichOF10.6418100%
10Francisco LindorSS10.8421100%
11Ronald AcunaOF12.1521100%
12Chris SaleSP12.3420100%
13Aaron JudgeOF13.7620100%
14Jose Altuve2B13.9634100%
15Alex Bregman3B, SS14.1822100%
16Bryce HarperOF14.3820100%
17Jacob deGromSP14.5920100%
18Paul Goldschmidt1B17.61222100%
19Freddie Freeman1B, 3B17.81422100%
20Trevor StorySS19.8929100%
21Giancarlo StantonOF21.31729100%
22Charlie BlackmonOF24.41634100%
23Justin VerlanderSP24.62231100%
24Corey KluberSP26.21837100%
25Javier Baez2B, 3B, SS26.41743100%
26Gerrit ColeSP26.82033100%
27Andrew BenintendiOF27.41849100%
28Kris Bryant3B, OF27.82133100%
29Aaron NolaSP28.91939100%
30Anthony Rizzo1B, 2B29.72336100%
31Blake SnellSP30.42436100%
32Trevor BauerSP32.41845100%
33Juan SotoOF34.12156100%
34Starling MarteOF37.03057100%
35Anthony Rendon3B37.72744100%
36Whit Merrifield1B, 2B, OF37.92752100%
37Luis SeverinoSP38.02557100%
38Khris DavisOF39.12655100%
39Noah SyndergaardSP40.72861100%
40Rhys Hoskins1B, OF40.72354100%
41Carlos CarrascoSP42.53649100%
42Carlos CorreaSS42.62982100%
43Cody Bellinger1B, OF43.93556100%
44Xander BogaertsSS44.32554100%
45Walker BuehlerSP, RP46.73556100%
46Eugenio Suarez3B48.93778100%
47George SpringerOF50.13975100%
48Lorenzo CainOF51.64165100%
49Clayton KershawSP51.629124100%
50Joey Votto1B52.94575100%
51Patrick CorbinSP56.13774100%
52Ozzie Albies2B58.24081100%
53Matt Carpenter1B, 2B, 3B58.834121100%
54James PaxtonSP58.94680100%
55Jose Abreu1B60.44484100%
56Vladimir Guerrero Jr.3B60.94281100%
57Stephen StrasburgSP61.44792100%
58Jean SeguraSS62.45187100%
59Justin UptonOF62.74690100%
60Mike ClevingerSP, RP63.23884100%
61Nelson CruzOF64.05095100%
62Edwin DiazRP64.845125100%
63J.T. RealmutoC, 1B65.433102100%
64Tommy PhamOF65.643103100%
65Zack GreinkeSP66.650124100%
66Corey SeagerSS67.451105100%
67Jameson TaillonSP67.547108100%
68Daniel Murphy1B, 2B72.45989100%
69Gary SanchezC73.152111100%
70Adalberto Mondesi2B, SS73.436103100%
71Mitch HanigerOF74.853148100%
72Marcell OzunaOF76.235168100%
73Blake TreinenRP76.957108100%
74Jesus Aguilar1B78.657106100%
75Nicholas Castellanos3B, OF79.157116100%
76Eddie RosarioOF79.455137100%
77Gleyber Torres2B, SS79.448125100%
78Jack FlahertySP79.557109100%
79Craig KimbrelRP80.850124100%
80Kenley JansenRP85.551120100%
81Scooter Gennett2B, 3B, OF86.066105100%
82Justin Turner3B86.260115100%
83Michael ConfortoOF86.453107100%
84Wil Myers1B, OF86.449140100%
85German MarquezSP86.954110100%
86Matt Chapman3B87.461127100%
87Zack WheelerSP87.942138100%
88Aroldis ChapmanRP88.674111100%
89Yasiel PuigOF88.760117100%
90A.J. PollockOF89.658165100%
91Josh Donaldson3B89.858139100%
92David PriceSP, RP90.359114100%
93Jose BerriosSP90.368107100%
94Aaron HicksOF90.855122100%
95Matt Olson1B, OF91.259112100%
96Travis Shaw3B92.055118100%
97Joey Gallo1B, 3B, OF98.670128100%
98Michael BrantleyOF100.277166100%
99Roberto OsunaRP100.983156100%
100Mike FoltynewiczSP102.181147100%
101Max Muncy1B, 2B, 3B, OF102.688136100%
102Brad HandRP103.584135100%
103Madison BumgarnerSP104.167182100%
104Felipe VazquezRP104.380119100%
105Miguel Andujar3B104.376141100%
106David DahlOF105.672123100%
107Andrew McCutchenOF106.464141100%
108Robinson Cano2B106.669127100%
109Edwin Encarnacion1B107.684140100%
110Miles MikolasSP108.344153100%
111Jonathan Villar2B, OF110.480171100%
112David PeraltaOF112.496126100%
113Masahiro TanakaSP112.879146100%
114Eloy JimenezOF114.182146100%
115Dee Gordon2B, OF116.485173100%
116Luis CastilloSP117.576199100%
117Sean DoolittleRP118.789144100%
118Jose Peraza2B, SS119.368149100%
119Rougned Odor2B120.895172100%
120Ender InciarteOF121.699180100%
121Victor RoblesOF121.891161100%
122Brian Dozier2B122.8101183100%
123Yu DarvishSP123.269192100%
124Mallex SmithOF124.279178100%
125Raisel IglesiasRP125.3100162100%
126Charlie MortonSP126.994164100%
127Rafael Devers3B128.9114161100%
128Robbie RaySP130.9107193100%
129Shohei OhtaniDH135.886171100%
130Mike Moustakas3B136.2114172100%
131Josh HaderRP138.394282100%
132Kyle HendricksSP138.7123180100%
133Stephen PiscottyOF141.0107166100%
134Nomar MazaraOF141.688203100%
135Jurickson Profar1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF145.999195100%
136Kirby YatesRP146.497175100%
137Willson ContrerasC146.7108204100%
138Carlos MartinezSP147.478257100%
139Yasmani GrandalC147.499180100%
140Wilson RamosC147.9127218100%
141Nick PivettaSP148.1115209100%
142Jose LeclercRP150.4119189100%
143Brandon NimmoOF151.3104211100%
144Tim AndersonSS153.6112271100%
145Wade DavisRP153.6133203100%
146J.A. HappSP153.6105186100%
147Salvador PerezC154.2120292100%
148Yoan Moncada2B154.4130223100%
149Eduardo RodriguezSP154.6107197100%
150Miguel Cabrera1B155.0113249100%
151Ian Desmond1B, OF155.1125209100%
152Ken GilesRP155.4118298100%
153Elvis AndrusSS156.4122291100%
154Chris ArcherSP157.2110198100%
155Amed RosarioSS157.7131233100%
156Cesar Hernandez2B158.2115206100%
157Buster PoseyC, 1B160.6143204100%
158Corey KnebelRP162.412818194%
159Jonathan Schoop2B163.2104243100%
160Yadier MolinaC165.1133190100%
161Kyle FreelandSP, RP166.699245100%
162Harrison BaderOF168.5139222100%
163Eric Hosmer1B170.1126246100%
164Ryan Braun1B, OF170.6122248100%
165Cole HamelsSP170.9144282100%
166Rich HillSP171.4111261100%
167Shane BieberSP172.6106218100%
168Nathan EovaldiSP173.2119254100%
169Andrew HeaneySP177.2116242100%
170Carlos Santana1B, OF177.4130263100%
171Adam EatonOF178.7121255100%
172Austin MeadowsOF182.1123260100%
173Paul DeJong2B, SS184.3131214100%
174Luke Voit1B184.5116248100%
175Ross StriplingSP, RP186.3120265100%
176Dallas KeuchelSP186.5129260100%
177Kyle SchwarberOF187.3140263100%
178Tyler GlasnowSP, RP188.7121266100%
179Billy HamiltonOF190.8143267100%
180Kenta MaedaSP191.8123279100%
181Cody AllenRP192.7153295100%
182Hunter RenfroeOF193.4160227100%
183Jose Martinez1B, OF193.6131261100%
184Andrelton SimmonsSS194.0171265100%
185Tyler SkaggsSP194.813921394%
186Justin Smoak1B196.8162264100%
187Jesse WinkerOF197.112822494%
188Gregory PolancoOF198.912126194%
189David RobertsonRP199.89423694%
190Corey DickersonOF201.1156249100%
191Jon LesterSP202.915725394%
192Alex WoodSP203.4135291100%
193Marcus SemienSS205.6167279100%
194Hyun-Jin RyuSP207.6161271100%
195Jose QuintanaSP208.7159296100%
196Shin-Soo ChooOF209.5169277100%
197Miguel Sano1B, 3B209.916129194%
198Yusei KikuchiP209.913429794%
199Jorge PolancoSS210.1161261100%
200Rick PorcelloSP210.1163295100%
201Yulieski Gurriel1B, 3B210.3147267100%
202Ramon LaureanoOF211.314025994%
203Byron BuxtonOF212.214229894%
204Franmil ReyesOF213.914922594%
205Kevin GausmanSP213.9161289100%
206Andrew MillerRP216.413228194%
207DJ LeMahieu2B216.917726294%
208Eduardo Escobar2B, 3B, SS217.713524789%
209Ketel Marte2B, SS218.8159258100%
210Alex ReyesSP222.914825089%
211Nick Senzel3B226.9179285100%
212Jed Lowrie2B, 3B229.3160261100%
213Josh Bell1B229.316529594%
214Jake Bauers1B, OF230.3150298100%
215Kyle Seager3B231.817827694%
216Josh JamesSP231.912423478%
217Jake ArrietaSP232.718029594%
218Odubel HerreraOF233.216128889%
219Tyler White1B233.813028894%
220Chris Taylor2B, SS, OF234.219328094%
221Garrett Hampson2B, SS234.715329494%
222Jonathan GraySP235.616129589%
223Michael FulmerSP236.816628689%
224Ian Happ2B, 3B, OF238.319428194%
225Danny JansenC239.918129394%
226Joey LucchesiSP242.518628894%
227Domingo SantanaOF245.015928489%
228Zack GodleySP245.717530089%
229Willy Adames2B, SS247.118429289%
230C.J. Cron1B247.419926494%
231Arodys VizcainoRP247.719325489%
232Will SmithSP, RP247.717427483%
233Joe MusgroveSP, RP248.013629978%
234Jake Lamb3B249.318127189%
235Manuel MargotOF249.320228694%
236Jackie BradleyOF249.814328889%
237Jimmy NelsonSP250.213829578%
238Max KeplerOF251.215129894%
239Archie BradleyRP251.719728483%
240Nick MarkakisOF259.720528683%
241Joey Wendle2B, OF260.119227183%
242Alex ColomeRP262.218430083%
243Collin McHughSP, RP264.517229778%
244Steven MatzSP264.919730094%
245Jordan HicksSP, RP265.416629978%
246Francisco MejiaC266.819629789%
247Peter Alonso1B270.815429889%
248Jose AlvaradoRP271.915529872%
249Trey Mancini1B, OF274.518329672%
250Randal GrichukOF274.620427878%
251Seranthony DominguezSP, RP276.118228678%
252A.J. MinterRP276.118029272%
253Lourdes Gurriel Jr.2B, SS, OF276.220126978%
254Welington CastilloC278.021329989%
255Jesus LuzardoSP278.416329978%
256Ryan Zimmerman1B279.919929783%
257Dellin BetancesRP282.416429072%
258Mychal GivensRP283.620728478%
259Maikel Franco3B289.320628878%
260Matt KempOF289.918129472%
261Brandon MorrowRP290.517929667%
262Kelvin HerreraRP290.619429967%
263Kyle TuckerOF290.623029883%
264Yonder Alonso1B290.721529472%
265Luke WeaverSP291.921030072%
266Sean NewcombSP293.018829567%
267Evan Longoria3B293.219528767%
268Asdrubal Cabrera2B, 3B, SS293.718528367%
269Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF294.822229778%
270Starlin Castro2B296.420829178%
271Brandon Belt1B, OF297.224729578%
272Sonny GraySP297.521629978%
273Adam JonesOF297.816230061%
274Mike SorokaSP299.814628561%
275Brian Anderson3B, OF303.924029672%
276Kyle GibsonSP304.120129272%
277Kendrys Morales1B309.124430072%
278Avisail GarciaOF309.919829767%
279Jay Bruce1B, OF310.122629267%
280Steven SouzaOF310.120229367%
281Pedro StropRP311.920429561%
282Didi GregoriusSS312.920730061%
283Teoscar HernandezOF312.920929967%
284Trevor MaySP, RP313.124629767%
285Mike ZuninoC314.223229361%
286Francisco CervelliC316.722829861%
287Jeremy JeffressRP317.018529156%
288Reynaldo LopezSP318.320828856%
289Carlos RodonSP319.724329961%
290Dylan BundySP321.424129967%
291Yan GomesC321.820529950%
292Marcus StromanSP327.123729656%
293Joc PedersonOF327.423429556%
294Matt BoydSP328.321327644%
295Willians AstudilloC, 3B329.622330056%
296Brett GardnerOF332.118827544%
297Chase AndersonSP333.623929750%
298Adam OttavinoRP334.422827844%
299Dereck RodriguezSP, RP334.420129650%
300Derek HollandSP334.816529739%

 

Catcher Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1J.T. RealmutoC, 1B65.433102100%
2Gary SanchezC73.152111100%
3Willson ContrerasC146.7108204100%
4Yasmani GrandalC147.499180100%
5Wilson RamosC147.9127218100%
6Salvador PerezC154.2120292100%
7Buster PoseyC, 1B160.6143204100%
8Yadier MolinaC165.1133190100%
9Danny JansenC239.918129394%
10Francisco MejiaC266.819629789%
11Welington CastilloC278.021329989%
12Mike ZuninoC314.223229361%
13Francisco CervelliC316.722829861%
14Yan GomesC321.820529950%
15Willians AstudilloC, 3B329.622330056%

 

1B Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Paul Goldschmidt1B17.61222100%
2Freddie Freeman1B, 3B17.81422100%
3Anthony Rizzo1B, 2B29.72336100%
4Whit Merrifield1B, 2B, OF37.92752100%
5Rhys Hoskins1B, OF40.72354100%
6Cody Bellinger1B, OF43.93556100%
7Joey Votto1B52.94575100%
8Matt Carpenter1B, 2B, 3B58.834121100%
9Jose Abreu1B60.44484100%
10J.T. RealmutoC, 1B65.433102100%
11Daniel Murphy1B, 2B72.45989100%
12Jesus Aguilar1B78.657106100%
13Wil Myers1B, OF86.449140100%
14Matt Olson1B, OF91.259112100%
15Joey Gallo1B, 3B, OF98.670128100%
16Max Muncy1B, 2B, 3B, OF102.688136100%
17Edwin Encarnacion1B107.684140100%
18Jurickson Profar1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF145.999195100%
19Miguel Cabrera1B155.0113249100%
20Ian Desmond1B, OF155.1125209100%
21Buster PoseyC, 1B160.6143204100%
22Eric Hosmer1B170.1126246100%
23Ryan Braun1B, OF170.6122248100%
24Carlos Santana1B, OF177.4130263100%
25Luke Voit1B184.5116248100%
26Jose Martinez1B, OF193.6131261100%
27Justin Smoak1B196.8162264100%
28Miguel Sano1B, 3B209.916129194%
29Yulieski Gurriel1B, 3B210.3147267100%
30Josh Bell1B229.316529594%
31Jake Bauers1B, OF230.3150298100%
32Tyler White1B233.813028894%
33C.J. Cron1B247.419926494%
34Peter Alonso1B270.815429889%
35Trey Mancini1B, OF274.518329672%
36Ryan Zimmerman1B279.919929783%
37Yonder Alonso1B290.721529472%
38Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF294.822229778%
39Brandon Belt1B, OF297.224729578%
40Kendrys Morales1B309.124430072%
41Jay Bruce1B, OF310.122629267%

 

2B Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Jose Ramirez2B, 3B3.135100%
2Jose Altuve2B13.9634100%
3Javier Baez2B, 3B, SS26.41743100%
4Whit Merrifield1B, 2B, OF37.92752100%
5Ozzie Albies2B58.24081100%
6Matt Carpenter1B, 2B, 3B58.834121100%
7Daniel Murphy1B, 2B72.45989100%
8Adalberto Mondesi2B, SS73.436103100%
9Gleyber Torres2B, SS79.448125100%
10Scooter Gennett2B, 3B, OF86.066105100%
11Max Muncy1B, 2B, 3B, OF102.688136100%
12Robinson Cano2B106.669127100%
13Jonathan Villar2B, OF110.480171100%
14Dee Gordon2B, OF116.485173100%
15Jose Peraza2B, SS119.368149100%
16Rougned Odor2B120.895172100%
17Brian Dozier2B122.8101183100%
18Jurickson Profar1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF145.999195100%
19Yoan Moncada2B154.4130223100%
20Cesar Hernandez2B158.2115206100%
21Jonathan Schoop2B163.2104243100%
22Paul DeJong2B, SS184.3131214100%
23DJ LeMahieu2B216.917726294%
24Eduardo Escobar2B, 3B, SS217.713524789%
25Ketel Marte2B, SS218.8159258100%
26Jed Lowrie2B, 3B229.3160261100%
27Chris Taylor2B, SS, OF234.219328094%
28Garrett Hampson2B, SS234.715329494%
29Ian Happ2B, 3B, OF238.319428194%
30Willy Adames2B, SS247.118429289%
31Joey Wendle2B, OF260.119227183%
32Lourdes Gurriel Jr.2B, SS, OF276.220126978%
33Asdrubal Cabrera2B, 3B, SS293.718528367%
34Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF294.822229778%
35Starlin Castro2B296.420829178%

 

3B Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Jose Ramirez2B, 3B3.135100%
2Nolan Arenado3B5.4311100%
3Manny Machado3B, SS9.8627100%
4Alex Bregman3B, SS14.1822100%
5Javier Baez2B, 3B, SS26.41743100%
6Kris Bryant3B, OF27.82133100%
7Anthony Rendon3B37.72744100%
8Eugenio Suarez3B48.93778100%
9Matt Carpenter1B, 2B, 3B58.834121100%
10Vladimir Guerrero Jr.3B60.94281100%
11Nicholas Castellanos3B, OF79.157116100%
12Scooter Gennett2B, 3B, OF86.066105100%
13Justin Turner3B86.260115100%
14Matt Chapman3B87.461127100%
15Josh Donaldson3B89.858139100%
16Travis Shaw3B92.055118100%
17Joey Gallo1B, 3B, OF98.670128100%
18Max Muncy1B, 2B, 3B, OF102.688136100%
19Miguel Andujar3B104.376141100%
20Rafael Devers3B128.9114161100%
21Mike Moustakas3B136.2114172100%
22Jurickson Profar1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF145.999195100%
23Miguel Sano1B, 3B209.916129194%
24Yulieski Gurriel1B, 3B210.3147267100%
25Eduardo Escobar2B, 3B, SS217.713524789%
26Nick Senzel3B226.9179285100%
27Jed Lowrie2B, 3B229.3160261100%
28Kyle Seager3B231.817827694%
29Ian Happ2B, 3B, OF238.319428194%
30Jake Lamb3B249.318127189%
31Maikel Franco3B289.320628878%
32Evan Longoria3B293.219528767%
33Asdrubal Cabrera2B, 3B, SS293.718528367%
34Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF294.822229778%
35Brian Anderson3B, OF303.924029672%
36Willians AstudilloC, 3B329.622330056%

 

SS Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Trea TurnerSS8.6416100%
2Manny Machado3B, SS9.8627100%
3Francisco LindorSS10.8421100%
4Alex Bregman3B, SS14.1822100%
5Trevor StorySS19.8929100%
6Javier Baez2B, 3B, SS26.41743100%
7Carlos CorreaSS42.62982100%
8Xander BogaertsSS44.32554100%
9Jean SeguraSS62.45187100%
10Corey SeagerSS67.451105100%
11Adalberto Mondesi2B, SS73.436103100%
12Gleyber Torres2B, SS79.448125100%
13Jose Peraza2B, SS119.368149100%
14Jurickson Profar1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF145.999195100%
15Tim AndersonSS153.6112271100%
16Elvis AndrusSS156.4122291100%
17Amed RosarioSS157.7131233100%
18Paul DeJong2B, SS184.3131214100%
19Andrelton SimmonsSS194.0171265100%
20Marcus SemienSS205.6167279100%
21Jorge PolancoSS210.1161261100%
22Eduardo Escobar2B, 3B, SS217.713524789%
23Ketel Marte2B, SS218.8159258100%
24Chris Taylor2B, SS, OF234.219328094%
25Garrett Hampson2B, SS234.715329494%
26Willy Adames2B, SS247.118429289%
27Lourdes Gurriel Jr.2B, SS, OF276.220126978%
28Asdrubal Cabrera2B, 3B, SS293.718528367%
29Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF294.822229778%
30Didi GregoriusSS312.920730061%

 

OF Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Mike TroutOF1.011100%
2Mookie BettsOF2.022100%
3J.D. MartinezOF5.148100%
4Christian YelichOF10.6418100%
5Ronald AcunaOF12.1521100%
6Aaron JudgeOF13.7620100%
7Bryce HarperOF14.3820100%
8Giancarlo StantonOF21.31729100%
9Charlie BlackmonOF24.41634100%
10Andrew BenintendiOF27.41849100%
11Kris Bryant3B, OF27.82133100%
12Juan SotoOF34.12156100%
13Starling MarteOF37.03057100%
14Whit Merrifield1B, 2B, OF37.92752100%
15Khris DavisOF39.12655100%
16Rhys Hoskins1B, OF40.72354100%
17Cody Bellinger1B, OF43.93556100%
18George SpringerOF50.13975100%
19Lorenzo CainOF51.64165100%
20Justin UptonOF62.74690100%
21Nelson CruzOF64.05095100%
22Tommy PhamOF65.643103100%
23Mitch HanigerOF74.853148100%
24Marcell OzunaOF76.235168100%
25Nicholas Castellanos3B, OF79.157116100%
26Eddie RosarioOF79.455137100%
27Scooter Gennett2B, 3B, OF86.066105100%
28Michael ConfortoOF86.453107100%
29Wil Myers1B, OF86.449140100%
30Yasiel PuigOF88.760117100%
31A.J. PollockOF89.658165100%
32Aaron HicksOF90.855122100%
33Matt Olson1B, OF91.259112100%
34Joey Gallo1B, 3B, OF98.670128100%
35Michael BrantleyOF100.277166100%
36Max Muncy1B, 2B, 3B, OF102.688136100%
37David DahlOF105.672123100%
38Andrew McCutchenOF106.464141100%
39Jonathan Villar2B, OF110.480171100%
40David PeraltaOF112.496126100%
41Eloy JimenezOF114.182146100%
42Dee Gordon2B, OF116.485173100%
43Ender InciarteOF121.699180100%
44Victor RoblesOF121.891161100%
45Mallex SmithOF124.279178100%
46Stephen PiscottyOF141.0107166100%
47Nomar MazaraOF141.688203100%
48Jurickson Profar1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF145.999195100%
49Brandon NimmoOF151.3104211100%
50Ian Desmond1B, OF155.1125209100%
51Harrison BaderOF168.5139222100%
52Ryan Braun1B, OF170.6122248100%
53Carlos Santana1B, OF177.4130263100%
54Adam EatonOF178.7121255100%
55Austin MeadowsOF182.1123260100%
56Kyle SchwarberOF187.3140263100%
57Billy HamiltonOF190.8143267100%
58Hunter RenfroeOF193.4160227100%
59Jose Martinez1B, OF193.6131261100%
60Jesse WinkerOF197.112822494%
61Gregory PolancoOF198.912126194%
62Corey DickersonOF201.1156249100%
63Shin-Soo ChooOF209.5169277100%
64Ramon LaureanoOF211.314025994%
65Byron BuxtonOF212.214229894%
66Franmil ReyesOF213.914922594%
67Jake Bauers1B, OF230.3150298100%
68Odubel HerreraOF233.216128889%
69Chris Taylor2B, SS, OF234.219328094%
70Ian Happ2B, 3B, OF238.319428194%
71Domingo SantanaOF245.015928489%
72Manuel MargotOF249.320228694%
73Jackie BradleyOF249.814328889%
74Max KeplerOF251.215129894%
75Nick MarkakisOF259.720528683%
76Joey Wendle2B, OF260.119227183%
77Trey Mancini1B, OF274.518329672%
78Randal GrichukOF274.620427878%
79Lourdes Gurriel Jr.2B, SS, OF276.220126978%
80Matt KempOF289.918129472%
81Kyle TuckerOF290.623029883%
82Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF294.822229778%
83Brandon Belt1B, OF297.224729578%
84Adam JonesOF297.816230061%
85Brian Anderson3B, OF303.924029672%
86Avisail GarciaOF309.919829767%
87Jay Bruce1B, OF310.122629267%
88Steven SouzaOF310.120229367%

 

SP Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Max ScherzerSP8.7618100%
2Chris SaleSP12.3420100%
3Jacob deGromSP14.5920100%
4Justin VerlanderSP24.62231100%
5Corey KluberSP26.21837100%
6Gerrit ColeSP26.82033100%
7Aaron NolaSP28.91939100%
8Blake SnellSP30.42436100%
9Trevor BauerSP32.41845100%
10Luis SeverinoSP38.02557100%
11Noah SyndergaardSP40.72861100%
12Carlos CarrascoSP42.53649100%
13Walker BuehlerSP, RP46.73556100%
14Clayton KershawSP51.629124100%
15Patrick CorbinSP56.13774100%
16James PaxtonSP58.94680100%
17Stephen StrasburgSP61.44792100%
18Mike ClevingerSP, RP63.23884100%
19Zack GreinkeSP66.650124100%
20Jameson TaillonSP67.547108100%
21Jack FlahertySP79.557109100%
22German MarquezSP86.954110100%
23Zack WheelerSP87.942138100%
24David PriceSP, RP90.359114100%
25Jose BerriosSP90.368107100%
26Mike FoltynewiczSP102.181147100%
27Madison BumgarnerSP104.167182100%
28Miles MikolasSP108.344153100%
29Masahiro TanakaSP112.879146100%
30Luis CastilloSP117.576199100%
31Yu DarvishSP123.269192100%
32Charlie MortonSP126.994164100%
33Robbie RaySP130.9107193100%
34Kyle HendricksSP138.7123180100%
35Carlos MartinezSP147.478257100%
36Nick PivettaSP148.1115209100%
37J.A. HappSP153.6105186100%
38Eduardo RodriguezSP154.6107197100%
39Chris ArcherSP157.2110198100%
40Kyle FreelandSP, RP166.699245100%
41Cole HamelsSP170.9144282100%
42Rich HillSP171.4111261100%
43Shane BieberSP172.6106218100%
44Nathan EovaldiSP173.2119254100%
45Andrew HeaneySP177.2116242100%
46Ross StriplingSP, RP186.3120265100%
47Dallas KeuchelSP186.5129260100%
48Tyler GlasnowSP, RP188.7121266100%
49Kenta MaedaSP191.8123279100%
50Tyler SkaggsSP194.813921394%
51Jon LesterSP202.915725394%
52Alex WoodSP203.4135291100%
53Hyun-Jin RyuSP207.6161271100%
54Jose QuintanaSP208.7159296100%
55Rick PorcelloSP210.1163295100%
56Kevin GausmanSP213.9161289100%
57Alex ReyesSP222.914825089%
58Josh JamesSP231.912423478%
59Jake ArrietaSP232.718029594%
60Jonathan GraySP235.616129589%
61Michael FulmerSP236.816628689%
62Joey LucchesiSP242.518628894%
63Zack GodleySP245.717530089%
64Will SmithSP, RP247.717427483%
65Joe MusgroveSP, RP248.013629978%
66Jimmy NelsonSP250.213829578%
67Collin McHughSP, RP264.517229778%
68Steven MatzSP264.919730094%
69Jordan HicksSP, RP265.416629978%
70Seranthony DominguezSP, RP276.118228678%
71Jesus LuzardoSP278.416329978%
72Luke WeaverSP291.921030072%
73Sean NewcombSP293.018829567%
74Sonny GraySP297.521629978%
75Mike SorokaSP299.814628561%
76Kyle GibsonSP304.120129272%
77Trevor MaySP, RP313.124629767%
78Reynaldo LopezSP318.320828856%
79Carlos RodonSP319.724329961%
80Dylan BundySP321.424129967%
81Marcus StromanSP327.123729656%
82Matt BoydSP328.321327644%
83Chase AndersonSP333.623929750%
84Dereck RodriguezSP, RP334.420129650%
85Derek HollandSP334.816529739%

 

RP Rankings

 

RankingPlayerPositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Edwin DiazRP64.845125100%
2Blake TreinenRP76.957108100%
3Craig KimbrelRP80.850124100%
4Kenley JansenRP85.551120100%
5Aroldis ChapmanRP88.674111100%
6Roberto OsunaRP100.983156100%
7Brad HandRP103.584135100%
8Felipe VazquezRP104.380119100%
9Sean DoolittleRP118.789144100%
10Raisel IglesiasRP125.3100162100%
11Josh HaderRP138.394282100%
12Kirby YatesRP146.497175100%
13Jose LeclercRP150.4119189100%
14Wade DavisRP153.6133203100%
15Ken GilesRP155.4118298100%
16Corey KnebelRP162.412818194%
17Ross StriplingSP, RP186.3120265100%
18Tyler GlasnowSP, RP188.7121266100%
19Cody AllenRP192.7153295100%
20David RobertsonRP199.89423694%
21Andrew MillerRP216.413228194%
22Arodys VizcainoRP247.719325489%
23Will SmithSP, RP247.717427483%
24Archie BradleyRP251.719728483%
25Alex ColomeRP262.218430083%
26Collin McHughSP, RP264.517229778%
27Jordan HicksSP, RP265.416629978%
28Jose AlvaradoRP271.915529872%
29Seranthony DominguezSP, RP276.118228678%
30A.J. MinterRP276.118029272%
31Dellin BetancesRP282.416429072%
32Mychal GivensRP283.620728478%
33Brandon MorrowRP290.517929667%
34Kelvin HerreraRP290.619429967%
35Pedro StropRP311.920429561%
36Trevor MaySP, RP313.124629767%
37Jeremy JeffressRP317.018529156%
38Adam OttavinoRP334.422827844%

 

Notes

 

Players who weren’t ranked on a list received a ranking of 400 for the purpose of creating the consensus ranking.

The “percent” column refers to what percentage of writers had this player listed in their top 300.

These lists were created solely for the 2019 season. Be sure to take that into account if you play in any type of keeper or dynasty league.

Writers who contributed are (in alphabetical order):

Andrew Gould, Anthony Messineo, Austin Bristow II, Ben Palmer, Ben Pernick, Charlie Wright, Colin Ward, Daniel Port, Evan Rockow, Jay Dunbar, John Hale, John Wallace, Jon Metzelaar, Kyle Monson, Max Freeze, Nathan Mills, Nick Pollack, Rich Holman, and Ryan Amore.

(Graphic by Justin Paradis, @freshmeatcomm on Twitter)

Myles Nelson

We Love Baseball manager, Myles started playing fantasy baseball as a middle-schooler in 2004 and hasn't stopped since. Now he just wants to share his love of baseball and why baseball is fun with everyone.

  • Avatar Rich Holman says:

    It should also be noted, players who have gotten injured in ST haven’t been properly adjusted. I would have players like Kershaw, Josh James, and Sal Perez much lower

  • Account / Login
    >