Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups For Week 24 (9/11 – 9/17): Who To Sit/Start

By | |


Every weekend here at Pitcher List, I review all expected starting pitcher matchups for the week ahead. There are three labels: StartMaybe, and Sit. Outings marked with a Maybe are circumstantial and dependent on your needs in a 12-teamer, while the other two are self-explanatory. Feel free to question my designations in the comments and we’ll dive into it together.

Here’s the massive table containing every Week 24 start from 9/11 – 9/17:

Date

Game

Away Pitcher

Sit/Start

Home Pitcher

Sit/Start

9/11

COL vs ARI

Jon Gray

Maybe

Zack Greinke

Start

9/11

DET vs CLE

Matthew Boyd

Sit

Carlos Carrasco

Start

9/11

CHW vs KCR

Reynaldo Lopez

Start

Jason Hammel

Sit

9/11

PIT vs MIL

Steven Brault

Sit

Brandon Woodruff

Maybe

9/11

LAD vs SFG

Kenta Maeda

Start

Chris Stratton

Sit

9/11

NYY vs TBR

CC Sabathia

Sit

Jake Odorizzi

Sit

9/11

SEA vs TEX

Ariel Miranda

Sit

Cole Hamels

Maybe

9/11

BAL vs TOR

Ubaldo Jimenez

Sit

Marco Estrada

Sit

9/12

COL vs ARI

Kyle Freeland

Sit

Taijuan Walker

Maybe

9/12

OAK vs BOS

Sean Manaea

Maybe

Eduardo Rodriguez

Maybe

9/12

NYM vs CHC

Matt Harvey

Sit

Jose Quintana

Start

9/12

DET vs CLE

Myles Jaye

Sit

Corey Kluber

Start

9/12

CHW vs KCR

TBA

Maybe

Sam Gaviglio

Sit

9/12

HOU vs LAA

Justin Verlander

Start

Garrett Richards

Maybe

9/12

PIT vs MIL

Gerrit Cole

Start

Brent Suter

Sit

9/12

SDP vs MIN

Travis Wood

Sit

Kyle Gibson

Maybe

9/12

MIA vs PHI

Dillon Peters

Maybe

Nick Pivetta

Sit

9/12

LAD vs SFG

Clayton Kershaw

Start

Ty Blach

Sit

9/12

CIN vs STL

Robert Stephenson

Maybe

Lance Lynn

Maybe

9/12

NYY vs TBR

Sonny Gray

Start

Blake Snell

Sit

9/12

SEA vs TEX

Andrew Moore

Sit

Miguel Gonzalez

Sit

9/12

BAL vs TOR

Kevin Gausman

Maybe

Joe Biagini

Maybe

9/12

ATL vs WSH

Luiz Gohara

Sit

Gio Gonzalez

Start

9/13

COL vs ARI

German Marquez

Sit

Patrick Corbin

Start

9/13

OAK vs BOS

Jharel Cotton

Sit

Doug Fister

Maybe

9/13

NYM vs CHC

Seth Lugo

Sit

Jon Lester

Start

9/13

DET vs CLE

Buck Farmer

Sit

Mike Clevinger

Start

9/13

CHW vs KCR

Lucas Giolito

Maybe

Ian Kennedy

Sit

9/13

HOU vs LAA

Lance McCullers Jr.

Start

Tyler Skaggs

Sit

9/13

PIT vs MIL

Trevor Williams

Sit

Matt Garza

Sit

9/13

SDP vs MIN

Dinelson Lamet

Maybe

Ervin Santana

Maybe

9/13

MIA vs PHI

Dan Straily

Maybe

Aaron Nola

Start

9/13

LAD vs SFG

Yu Darvish

Start

Johnny Cueto

Maybe

9/13

CIN vs STL

Tyler Mahle

Sit

Luke Weaver

Start

9/13

NYY vs TBR

Jaime Garcia

Sit

Chris Archer

Start

9/13

SEA vs TEX

Mike Leake

Sit

Martin Perez

Sit

9/13

BAL vs TOR

Dylan Bundy

Start

Marcus Stroman

Start

9/13

ATL vs WSH

Julio Teheran

Sit

Tanner Roark

Start

9/14

COL vs ARI

Chad Bettis

Sit

Zack Godley

Start

9/14

OAK vs BOS

Daniel Gossett

Sit

Drew Pomeranz

Start

9/14

NYM vs CHC

Chris Flexen

Sit

John Lackey

Maybe

9/14

KCR vs CLE

Jake Junis

Maybe

Josh Tomlin

Sit

9/14

CHW vs DET

James Shields

Sit

Chad Bell

Sit

9/14

HOU vs LAA

Brad Peacock

Start

Ricky Nolasco

Sit

9/14

TOR vs MIN

Brett Anderson

Sit

Jose Berrios

Start

9/14

BAL vs NYY

Wade Miley

Sit

Masahiro Tanaka

Start

9/14

MIA vs PHI

Jose Urena

Sit

Jake Thompson

Sit

9/14

CIN vs STL

Amir Garrett

Sit

Carlos Martinez

Start

9/14

SEA vs TEX

Andrew Albers

Sit

Andrew Cashner

Sit

9/14

ATL vs WSH

Sean Newcomb

Sit

Max Scherzer

Start

9/15

NYM vs ATL

Rafael Montero

Maybe

Mike Foltynewicz

Maybe

9/15

STL vs CHC

Michael Wacha

Maybe

Mike Montgomery

Sit

9/15

PIT vs CIN

Chad Kuhl

Sit

Homer Bailey

Sit

9/15

KCR vs CLE

Jason Vargas

Sit

Trevor Bauer

Start

9/15

SDP vs COL

Clayton Richard

Sit

Tyler Chatwood

Sit

9/15

CHW vs DET

Carson Fulmer

Sit

Anibal Sanchez

Sit

9/15

SEA vs HOU

Erasmo Ramirez

Sit

Dallas Keuchel

Start

9/15

TEX vs LAA

A.J. Griffin

Sit

TBA

Maybe

9/15

MIL vs MIA

Chase Anderson

Start

Adam Conley

Sit

9/15

TOR vs MIN

J.A. Happ

Start

Bartolo Colon

Sit

9/15

BAL vs NYY

Jeremy Hellickson

Sit

Luis Severino

Start

9/15

OAK vs PHI

Daniel Mengden

Sit

Mark Leiter Jr.

Sit

9/15

ARI vs SFG

Robbie Ray

Start

Matt Moore

Sit

9/15

BOS vs TBR

Chris Sale

Start

Jacob Faria?

Sit

9/15

LAD vs WSH

Alex Wood

Start

Edwin Jackson

Sit

9/16

NYM vs ATL

Jacob deGrom

Start

Max Fried

Sit

9/16

STL vs CHC

Adam Wainwright

Sit

Kyle Hendricks

Maybe

9/16

PIT vs CIN

Ivan Nova

Sit

Sal Romano

Sit

9/16

KCR vs CLE

Jason Hammel

Sit

Carlos Carrasco

Start

9/16

SDP vs COL

Jordan Lyles

Sit

Jon Gray

Start

9/16

CHW vs DET

Reynaldo Lopez

Start

Matthew Boyd

Sit

9/16

SEA vs HOU

Ariel Miranda

Sit

Charlie Morton

Start

9/16

TEX vs LAA

Cole Hamels

Maybe

Parker Bridwell

Sit

9/16

MIL vs MIA

Zach Davies

Maybe

Odrisamer Despaigne

Sit

9/16

TOR vs MIN

Marco Estrada

Sit

Adalberto Mejia

Sit

9/16

BAL vs NYY

Ubaldo Jimenez

Sit

CC Sabathia

Sit

9/16

OAK vs PHI

Kendall Graveman

Maybe

Ben Lively

Sit

9/16

ARI vs SFG

Zack Greinke

Start

Jeff Samardzija

Maybe

9/16

BOS vs TBR

Rick Porcello

Sit

Matt Andriese

Sit

9/16

LAD vs WSH

Rich Hill

Start

Stephen Strasburg

Start

9/17

NYM vs ATL

Matt Harvey

Sit

R.A. Dickey

Sit

9/17

STL vs CHC

Lance Lynn

Maybe

Jose Quintana

Start

9/17

PIT vs CIN

Gerrit Cole

Start

Robert Stephenson

Maybe

9/17

KCR vs CLE

Sam Gaviglio

Maybe

Corey Kluber

Start

9/17

SDP vs COL

Jhoulys Chacin

Sit

Kyle Freeland

Sit

9/17

CHW vs DET

TBA

Sit

Myles Jaye

Sit

9/17

SEA vs HOU

Andrew Moore

Sit

Justin Verlander

Start

9/17

TEX vs LAA

Miguel Gonzalez

Sit

Garrett Richards

Start

9/17

MIL vs MIA

Brandon Woodruff

Sit

Dillon Peters

Maybe

9/17

TOR vs MIN

Joe Biagini

Maybe

Kyle Gibson

Maybe

9/17

BAL vs NYY

Kevin Gausman

Maybe

Sonny Gray

Start

9/17

OAK vs PHI

Sean Manaea

Start

Nick Pivetta

Sit

9/17

ARI vs SFG

Taijuan Walker

Start

Madison Bumgarner

Start

9/17

BOS vs TBR

Eduardo Rodriguez

Maybe

Alex Cobb

Sit

9/17

LAD vs WSH

Kenta Maeda

Start

Gio Gonzalez

Maybe

The following two tabs change content below.

Nick Pollack

Founder
Founder of both PitcherList.com and PitcherGIFs.com. Rotographs and Washington Post contributor and has worked with CBS Sports, Grantland, and SB Nation. Former pitching coach and Brandeis alum.

Latest posts by Nick Pollack (see all)

13 Responses to “Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups For Week 24 (9/11 – 9/17): Who To Sit/Start”

  1. DJ September 11, 2017

    Keeper question for next year. $18 fulmer or $15 taillon.

    Reply
    • Nick Pollack

      I’d want to hear more about Fulmer’s situation before making this decision, but I like Fulmer a little more than Taillon.

      Reply
      • Drew

        Unfortunately got caught in a situation where I need to drop one of them. They not even make my final keepers but always good to have options

        Reply
  2. John

    12tm H2H pts. Rank SP options this week: 2x starters Stephenson, Gibson, Hammel, Erod, Peters, Richards or 1 starts of Lester or Godley

    Reply
  3. shudd1

    Would you start a two-start Reynaldo Lopez or Nola vs. Miami? Seems like Nola has struggled when he’s faced the Marlins this season. Other possibility is Morton.

    Reply
  4. Cubblue1

    Would you consider streaming Sabathia this week since he has 2 starts or is this a bad idea? I could instead stream McCullers, Weaver, Morton, Anderson and/or Richards later this week although it would use up another add…

    Reply
  5. Nick Pollack

    I’d prefer any of McCullers/Weaver/Anderson over two of Sabatha. Probably Weaver with the way he’s rolling.

    Reply
  6. thomasfrailrx

    Am I overthinking this?

    I’m between Yu Darvish and Garrett Richards this week. It’s a weekly league so it can only be one or the other. Darvish has had great outings against the Yankees, but his injury bugs me. Garrett Richards looked decent enough in his return and I’m all in on him against Texas, but the Houston matchup might burn me. Thoughts?

    Reply
  7. John

    12 H2H pts. Rank SP options this week: 2x starters Stephenson, Gibson, Hammel, Erod, Peters, Richards, Gibson,or 1 starts of Lester or Godley
    Reply

    Reply

Comments