Pitcher List’s Staff Consensus Top 300 Overall Players

It’s time for some rankings! 19 of our writers sent in their personal top 300 rankings, and we’ve combined them all to give to you the consensus rankings for our site. Use these rankings to help you gauge trade value, to help you create your own draft rankings, and to see how players are valued by a large group of industry writers.

These rankings were made with H2H 5×5 12-teamers in mind. These were also done prior to some of the most recent news, such as Mike Moustakas signing with the Royals and Marcus Stroman’s shoulder inflammation.

Overall Top 300

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Mike TroutOF1.112100%
2Jose Altuve2B1.912100%
3Nolan Arenado3B4.137100%
4Mookie BettsOF5.9310100%
5Bryce HarperOF6.3313100%
6Trea TurnerSS6.3314100%
7Paul Goldschmidt1B7.1314100%
8Charlie BlackmonOF9.6320100%
9Giancarlo StantonOF9.6624100%
10Clayton KershawSP9.8517100%
11Carlos CorreaSS9.9315100%
12Kris Bryant3B11.5622100%
13Joey Votto1B14.2620100%
14Max ScherzerSP15.31120100%
15Chris SaleSP16.11221100%
16Manny Machado3B16.31124100%
17Francisco LindorSS16.5824100%
18Corey KluberSP17.81522100%
19Freddie Freeman1B19.41234100%
20Aaron JudgeOF19.91230100%
21Anthony Rizzo1B20.11424100%
22J.D. MartinezOF22.91731100%
23Jose Ramirez2B, 3B23.71837100%
24George SpringerOF25.52235100%
25Josh Donaldson3B26.51136100%
26Corey SeagerSS26.61542100%
27Stephen StrasburgSP27.42235100%
28Cody Bellinger1B, OF28.62062100%
29Noah SyndergaardSP28.72334100%
30Madison BumgarnerSP29.82551100%
31Gary SanchezC31.82146100%
32Brian Dozier2B33.52940100%
33Luis SeverinoSP33.82552100%
34Jacob deGromSP34.22640100%
35Alex Bregman3B, SS39.02655100%
36Jose Abreu1B39.82955100%
37Zack GreinkeSP40.12657100%
38Dee Gordon2B40.33167100%
39Anthony Rendon3B41.03060100%
40Rhys Hoskins1B, OF43.927103100%
41Carlos CarrascoSP44.93664100%
42Christian YelichOF45.43864100%
43Yu DarvishSP46.02355100%
44Justin UptonOF46.13073100%
45Marcell OzunaOF46.53274100%
46Justin Turner3B47.82972100%
47Andrew BenintendiOF50.24076100%
48Carlos MartinezSP52.83876100%
49Daniel Murphy2B53.24073100%
50Justin VerlanderSP54.63890100%
51Kenley JansenRP55.14071100%
52Nelson CruzDH56.128116100%
53Aaron NolaSP56.13978100%
54Starling MarteOF58.23695100%
55James PaxtonSP60.04686100%
56Chris ArcherSP60.34676100%
57Wil Myers1B60.53688100%
58Byron BuxtonOF61.84385100%
59Craig KimbrelRP62.44481100%
60Elvis AndrusSS62.64180100%
61Tommy PhamOF63.953143100%
62Edwin Encarnacion1B65.135127100%
63Robbie RaySP66.443127100%
64Dallas KeuchelSP67.14998100%
65Willson ContrerasC68.04588100%
66Buster PoseyC73.65194100%
67Jean SeguraSS73.852104100%
68Robinson Cano2B74.253100100%
69Yoenis CespedesOF74.66097100%
70A.J. PollockOF74.742101100%
71Whit Merrifield2B75.139141100%
72Eric Hosmer1B77.057115100%
73Xander BogaertsSS81.452108100%
74Andrew McCutchenOF82.364105100%
75Gerrit ColeSP82.542130100%
76Lorenzo CainOF82.760104100%
77Jose QuintanaSP82.862103100%
78Billy HamiltonOF83.861182100%
79Masahiro TanakaSP84.567116100%
80Domingo SantanaOF85.559138100%
81Corey KnebelRP87.162116100%
82Aroldis ChapmanRP88.363123100%
83Shohei OhtaniSP88.658155100%
84Khris DavisOF88.646166100%
85Roberto OsunaRP89.775119100%
86David PriceSP89.847151100%
87Luis CastilloSP91.666110100%
88Jonathan Schoop2B91.948146100%
89Ryan BraunOF92.974138100%
90Jake ArrietaSP94.556117100%
91Felipe RiveroRP94.571127100%
92Lance McCullersSP97.343151100%
93Yasiel PuigOF97.957163100%
94Alex WoodSP98.663155100%
95Justin Smoak1B99.370143100%
96Zack GodleySP101.765136100%
97Jake Lamb3B101.96317595%
98Travis Shaw3B102.672195100%
99Kyle Seager3B103.664165100%
100Marcus StromanSP103.739167100%
101Miguel Sano3B105.359166100%
102Miguel Cabrera1B105.663192100%
103Sonny GraySP107.552175100%
104Salvador PerezC109.277190100%
105Ender InciarteOF111.183152100%
106Ken GilesRP112.167157100%
107Rougned Odor2B112.477200100%
108Edwin DiazRP112.482135100%
109Adam EatonOF112.590166100%
110Chris Taylor2B, OF115.678154100%
111Matt Carpenter1B116.769187100%
112Kyle HendricksSP117.389176100%
113Joey Gallo1B, 3B117.485184100%
114J.T. RealmutoC119.380208100%
115Cody AllenRP120.693161100%
116Wade DavisRP121.272150100%
117Yoan Moncada2B121.470166100%
118Jose BerriosSP121.883179100%
119Rafael Devers3B122.179184100%
120Luke WeaverSP123.486169100%
121Adrian Beltre3B123.959223100%
122Michael FulmerSP124.292173100%
123Raisel IglesiasRP125.589148100%
124Jon LesterSP126.8102157100%
125D.J. LeMahieu2B127.589207100%
126Matt Olson1B130.765182100%
127Jon GraySP132.878179100%
128Mike Moustakas3B133.387270100%
129Greg Bird1B134.195185100%
130Gregory PolancoOF134.7100171100%
131Carlos Santana1B135.2101169100%
132Nick Castellanos3B136.996176100%
133Danny DuffySP139.7102175100%
134Johnny CuetoSP140.7100252100%
135Eddie RosarioOF141.266223100%
136Manuel MargotOF142.4105256100%
137Michael ConfortoOF142.885191100%
138Didi GregoriusSS143.286187100%
139Trevor StorySS147.591217100%
140Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, SS, OF148.1117197100%
141Sean DoolittleRP151.9101280100%
142Adam JonesOF152.590219100%
143Ryan Zimmerman1B153.680217100%
144Garrett RichardsSP153.7124194100%
145Eduardo Nunez2B, 3B, OF154.390202100%
146Rich HillSP154.783254100%
147Nomar MazaraOF155.4107249100%
148Jameson TaillonSP157.1117237100%
149Ian Happ2B, OF159.2108227100%
150Kyle SchwarberOF160.7108212100%
151Brad HandRP161.386245100%
152Drew PomeranzSP161.498238100%
153Javier Baez2B, SS161.799209100%
154Steven SouzaOF161.8115269100%
155Alex ColomeRP161.9120183100%
156Kevin KiermaierOF163.5125292100%
157Evan Longoria3B163.6120210100%
158Jeff SamardzijaSP165.1120271100%
159Mark MelanconRP167.6143197100%
160Ian Kinsler2B170.2129231100%
161Dylan BundySP171.8115297100%
162Mitch HanigerOF172.3123231100%
163Chase AndersonSP173.7113242100%
164Justin Bour1B173.9120215100%
165Josh Bell1B174.2138216100%
166Trevor BauerSP174.3116231100%
167Ozzie Albies2B176.188291100%
168Eugenio Suarez3B177.8109244100%
169Hector NerisRP179.1139248100%
170Danny SalazarSP179.213721795%
171Kenta MaedaSP180.197271100%
172Jacob FariaSP180.6147240100%
173Zack CozartSS181.3118248100%
174Gio GonzalezSP182.7145213100%
175Evan GattisC183.489262100%
176Taijuan WalkerSP184.510823995%
177Archie BradleyRP185.012425695%
178Ian Desmond1B, OF185.8100277100%
179Charlie MortonSP187.1130212100%
180Jay BruceOF189.1133249100%
181Brett GardnerOF190.4133293100%
182Bradley ZimmerOF190.7105233100%
183Jorge PolancoSS190.9143273100%
184Jeurys FamiliaRP191.3141273100%
185Kelvin HerreraRP192.3128295100%
186Kevin GausmanSP192.5140271100%
187Eric Thames1B, OF194.414624195%
188Paul DeJong2B, SS195.6126254100%
189Sean ManaeaSP196.2142279100%
190Andrew MillerRP196.7150245100%
191Welington CastilloC198.4137299100%
192Dexter FowlerOF198.9127271100%
193Blake SnellSP199.9152253100%
194Jason Kipnis2B201.88828995%
195Patrick CorbinSP204.7161274100%
196Adam DuvallOF205.779296100%
197Yadier MolinaC206.914624395%
198Wilson RamosC208.1151276100%
199Odubel HerreraOF209.115025595%
200Aaron AltherrOF210.5141268100%
201Michael WachaSP210.614229595%
202Addison RussellSS211.115527795%
203Chris Davis1B212.016126095%
204Andrelton SimmonsSS212.612924995%
205Greg HollandRP213.315025895%
206Jose Martinez1B, OF214.977291100%
207Mike ClevingerSP215.513029789%
208Trey Mancini1B, OF215.9127297100%
209Scooter Gennett2B216.7137285100%
210Yuli Gurriel1B216.8169251100%
211Arodys VizcainoRP217.213828695%
212Orlando ArciaSS218.4147299100%
213Aaron SanchezSP218.9160283100%
214Aaron HicksOF219.3165300100%
215Delino DeShieldsOF220.616929495%
216Cole HamelsSP221.714730095%
217Jordan MontgomerySP227.0168286100%
218Blake TreinenRP227.415728295%
219Jonathan LucroyC228.713526589%
220Ronald AcunaOF229.29424774%
221Starlin Castro2B230.1174275100%
222Marcus SemienSS231.315629895%
223Avisail GarciaOF232.9136294100%
224Brandon Belt1B234.515925284%
225Carlos GonzalezOF238.211728895%
226Corey DickersonOF239.816327189%
227Max KeplerOF240.114429289%
228Matt Chapman3B241.119729695%
229Scott ScheblerOF242.317727789%
230Alex ReyesSP242.813428889%
231Julio TeheranSP242.918529695%
232Tim AndersonSS243.819327495%
233Jackie BradleyOF244.718727595%
234Yasmani GrandalC245.714529189%
235Hanley RamirezDH245.8184290100%
236Josh Harrison2B, 3B249.419229295%
237Yonder Alonso1B250.4209299100%
238Austin BarnesC251.2170296100%
239Jose Peraza2B, SS251.917228079%
240Tanner RoarkSP252.120828695%
241Shin-Soo ChooOF252.314128689%
242Lance LynnSP254.417028189%
243David PeraltaOF255.519929195%
244Maikel Franco3B256.019429795%
245Todd Frazier3B259.218028995%
246Brandon MorrowRP260.512723563%
247Jake OdorizziSP261.720429853%
248Stephen PiscottyOF263.120730095%
249Blake ParkerRP264.415426979%
250Alex CobbSP265.116729395%
251Mark TrumboOF267.216629684%
252Willie CalhounOF270.412928474%
253Felix HernandezSP270.616029474%
254Michael BrantleyOF272.416227674%
255Mike ZuninoC272.515929774%
256Josh ReddickOF272.717729984%
257Dellin BetancesRP272.817927484%
258Kole CalhounOF276.819028784%
259Carlos RodonSP278.513929774%
260Jimmy NelsonSP278.920630079%
261Ervin SantanaSP281.719528879%
262Chad GreenRP283.419728274%
263Dinelson LametSP284.818928168%
264David DahlOF287.121229979%
265Brian McCannC289.316828563%
266Amed RosarioSS289.821729179%
267Brad BrachRP291.311924658%
268Cesar Hernandez2B292.317228168%
269Joc PedersonOF294.317930058%
270Ryon Healy1B, 3B299.920129968%
271Brad PeacockSP/RP301.115828058%
272Cam BedrosianRP301.920729663%
273Carl EdwardsRP302.715628547%
274Collin McHughSP303.121129863%
275Derek FisherOF305.520329858%
276J.A. HappSP309.321329958%
277Zach BrittonRP310.219129663%
278Chris DevenskiRP310.223829868%
279Jonathan Villar2B310.617928958%
280Alex ClaudioRP311.621229558%
281Chris Owings2B, SS, OF313.821729868%
282Tim BeckhamSS316.819729458%
283Shane GreeneRP317.221929158%
284Randall GrichukOF317.823230063%
285Eduardo RodriguezSP318.221930063%
286Luiz GoharaSP319.319530058%
287Tyler FlowersC321.318925942%
288Zach DaviesSP321.822829853%
289Steven MatzSP322.623426853%
290Gleyber TorresSS323.718328853%
291Ryan Mcmahon1B323.817427047%
292Fernando RodneyRP324.119327447%
293Michael TaylorOF324.415229247%
294German MarquezSP324.521528347%
295Rick PorcelloSP324.721928553%
296Francisco MejiaDH326.718628347%
297Yasmany TomasOF327.320429442%
298Josh HaderRP328.625430058%
299Kevin PillarOF329.421929658%
300Hunter RenfroeOF329.719929953%

Catcher Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Gary SanchezC31.82146100%
2Willson ContrerasC68.04588100%
3Buster PoseyC73.65194100%
4Salvador PerezC109.277190100%
5J.T. RealmutoC119.380208100%
6Evan GattisC183.489262100%
7Welington CastilloC198.4137299100%
8Yadier MolinaC206.914624395%
9Wilson RamosC208.1151276100%
10Jonathan LucroyC228.713526589%
11Yasmani GrandalC245.714529189%
12Austin BarnesC251.2170296100%
13Mike ZuninoC272.515929774%
14Brian McCannC289.316828563%
15Tyler FlowersC321.318925942%
16Robinson ChirinosC350.621529937%

1B Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Paul Goldschmidt1B7.1314100%
2Joey Votto1B14.2620100%
3Freddie Freeman1B19.41234100%
4Anthony Rizzo1B20.11424100%
5Cody Bellinger1B, OF28.62062100%
6Jose Abreu1B39.82955100%
7Rhys Hoskins1B, OF43.927103100%
8Wil Myers1B60.53688100%
9Edwin Encarnacion1B65.135127100%
10Eric Hosmer1B77.057115100%
11Justin Smoak1B99.370143100%
12Miguel Cabrera1B105.663192100%
13Matt Carpenter1B116.769187100%
14Joey Gallo1B, 3B117.485184100%
15Matt Olson1B130.765182100%
16Greg Bird1B134.195185100%
17Carlos Santana1B135.2101169100%
18Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, SS, OF148.1117197100%
19Ryan Zimmerman1B153.680217100%
20Justin Bour1B173.9120215100%
21Josh Bell1B174.2138216100%
22Ian Desmond1B, OF185.8100277100%
23Eric Thames1B, OF194.414624195%
24Chris Davis1B212.016126095%
25Jose Martinez1B, OF214.977291100%
26Trey Mancini1B, OF215.9127297100%
27Yuli Gurriel1B216.8169251100%
28Brandon Belt1B234.515925284%
29Yonder Alonso1B250.4209299100%
30Ryon Healy1B, 3B299.920129968%
31Ryan McMahon1B323.817427047%
32Logan Morrison1B332.422228547%

2B Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Jose Altuve2B1.912100%
2Jose Ramirez2B, 3B23.71837100%
3Brian Dozier2B33.52940100%
4Dee Gordon2B40.33167100%
5Daniel Murphy2B53.24073100%
6Robinson Cano2B74.253100100%
7Whit Merrifield2B75.139141100%
8Jonathan Schoop2B91.948146100%
9Rougned Odor2B112.477200100%
10Chris Taylor2B, OF115.678154100%
11Yoan Moncada2B121.470166100%
12D.J. LeMahieu2B127.589207100%
13Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, SS, OF148.1117197100%
14Eduardo Nunez2B, 3B, OF154.390202100%
15Ian Happ2B, OF159.2108227100%
16Javier Baez2B, SS161.799209100%
17Ian Kinsler2B170.2129231100%
18Ozzie Albies2B176.188291100%
19Paul DeJong2B, SS195.6126254100%
20Jason Kipnis2B201.88828995%
21Scooter Gennett2B216.7137285100%
22Starlin Castro2B230.1174275100%
23Josh Harrison2B, 3B249.419229295%
24Jose Peraza2B, SS251.917228079%
25Cesar Hernandez2B292.317228168%
26Jonathan Villar2B310.617928958%
27Chris Owings2B, SS, OF313.821729868%
28Joe Panik2B330.422225542%
29Yangervis Solarte2B, 3B, SS341.127429953%
30Devon Travis2B345.823329237%
31Scott Kingery2B351.225929542%

3B Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Nolan Arenado3B4.137100%
2Kris Bryant3B11.5622100%
3Manny Machado3B16.31124100%
4Jose Ramirez2B, 3B23.71837100%
5Josh Donaldson3B26.51136100%
6Alex Bregman3B, SS39.02655100%
7Anthony Rendon3B41.03060100%
8Justin Turner3B47.82972100%
9Jake Lamb3B101.96317595%
10Travis Shaw3B102.672195100%
11Kyle Seager3B103.664165100%
12Miguel Sano3B105.359166100%
13Joey Gallo1B, 3B117.485184100%
14Rafael Devers3B122.179184100%
15Adrian Beltre3B123.959223100%
16Mike Moustakas3B133.387270100%
17Nick Castellanos3B136.996176100%
18Eduardo Nunez2B, 3B, OF154.390202100%
19Evan Longoria3B163.6120210100%
20Eugenio Suarez3B177.8109244100%
21Matt Chapman3B241.119729695%
22Josh Harrison2B, 3B249.419229295%
23Maikel Franco3B256.019429795%
24Todd Frazier3B259.218028995%
25Ryon Healy1B, 3B299.920129968%
26Yangervis Solarte2B, 3B, SS341.127429953%
27Jedd Gyorko3B354.624529437%
28Eduardo Escobar3B355.523729537%

SS Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Trea TurnerSS6.3314100%
2Carlos CorreaSS9.9315100%
3Francisco LindorSS16.5824100%
4Corey SeagerSS26.61542100%
5Alex Bregman3B, SS39.02655100%
6Elvis AndrusSS62.64180100%
7Jean SeguraSS73.852104100%
8Xander BogaertsSS81.452108100%
9Didi GregoriusSS143.286187100%
10Trevor StorySS147.591217100%
11Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, SS, OF148.1117197100%
12Javier Baez2B, SS161.799209100%
13Zack CozartSS181.3118248100%
14Jorge PolancoSS190.9143273100%
15Paul DeJong2B, SS195.6126254100%
16Addison RussellSS211.115527795%
17Andrelton SimmonsSS212.612924995%
18Orlando ArciaSS218.4147299100%
19Marcus SemienSS231.315629895%
20Tim AndersonSS243.819327495%
21Jose Peraza2B, SS251.917228079%
22Amed RosarioSS289.821729179%
23Chris Owings2B, SS, OF313.821729868%
24Tim BeckhamSS316.819729458%
25Gleyber TorresSS323.718328853%
26Dansby SwansonSS335.423129447%

OF Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Mike TroutOF1.112100%
2Mookie BettsOF5.9310100%
3Bryce HarperOF6.3313100%
4Charlie BlackmonOF9.6320100%
5Giancarlo StantonOF9.6624100%
6Aaron JudgeOF19.91230100%
7J.D. MartinezOF22.91731100%
8George SpringerOF25.52235100%
9Cody Bellinger1B, OF28.62062100%
10Rhys Hoskins1B, OF43.927103100%
11Christian YelichOF45.43864100%
12Justin UptonOF46.13073100%
13Marcell OzunaOF46.53274100%
14Andrew BenintendiOF50.24076100%
15Starling MarteOF58.23695100%
16Byron BuxtonOF61.84385100%
17Tommy PhamOF63.953143100%
18Yoenis CespedesOF74.66097100%
19A.J. PollockOF74.742101100%
20Andrew McCutchenOF82.364105100%
21Lorenzo CainOF82.760104100%
22Billy HamiltonOF83.861182100%
23Domingo SantanaOF85.559138100%
24Khris DavisOF88.646166100%
25Ryan BraunOF92.974138100%
26Yasiel PuigOF97.957163100%
27Ender InciarteOF111.183152100%
28Adam EatonOF112.590166100%
29Chris Taylor2B, OF115.678154100%
30Gregory PolancoOF134.7100171100%
31Eddie RosarioOF141.266223100%
32Manuel MargotOF142.4105256100%
33Michael ConfortoOF142.885191100%
34Marwin Gonzalez1B, 2B, SS, OF148.1117197100%
35Adam JonesOF152.590219100%
36Eduardo Nunez2B, 3B, OF154.390202100%
37Nomar MazaraOF155.4107249100%
38Ian Happ2B, OF159.2108227100%
39Kyle SchwarberOF160.7108212100%
40Steven SouzaOF161.8115269100%
41Kevin KiermaierOF163.5125292100%
42Mitch HanigerOF172.3123231100%
43Ian Desmond1B, OF185.8100277100%
44Jay BruceOF189.1133249100%
45Brett GardnerOF190.4133293100%
46Bradley ZimmerOF190.7105233100%
47Eric Thames1B, OF194.414624195%
48Dexter FowlerOF198.9127271100%
49Adam DuvallOF205.779296100%
50Odubel HerreraOF209.115025595%
51Aaron AltherrOF210.5141268100%
52Jose Martinez1B, OF214.977291100%
53Trey Mancini1B, OF215.9127297100%
54Aaron HicksOF219.3165300100%
55Delino DeShieldsOF220.616929495%
56Ronald AcunaOF229.29424774%
57Avisail GarciaOF232.9136294100%
58Carlos GonzalezOF238.211728895%
59Corey DickersonOF239.816327189%
60Max KeplerOF240.114429289%
61Scott ScheblerOF242.317727789%
62Jackie BradleyOF244.718727595%
63Shin-Soo ChooOF252.314128689%
64David PeraltaOF255.519929195%
65Stephen PiscottyOF263.120730095%
66Mark TrumboOF267.216629684%
67Willie CalhounOF270.412928474%
68Michael BrantleyOF272.416227674%
69Josh ReddickOF272.717729984%
70Kole CalhounOF276.819028784%
71David DahlOF287.121229979%
72Joc PedersonOF294.317930058%
73Derek FisherOF305.520329858%
74Chris Owings2B, SS, OF313.821729868%
75Randall GrichukOF317.823230063%
76Michael TaylorOF324.415229247%
77Yasmany TomasOF327.320429442%
78Kevin PillarOF329.421929658%
79Hunter RenfroeOF329.719929953%
80Lewis BrinsonOF336.716929947%
81Matt KempOF336.822929047%
82Nick WilliamsOF339.622028542%
83Alex DickersonOF342.422328737%

SP Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Clayton KershawSP9.8517100%
2Max ScherzerSP15.31120100%
3Chris SaleSP16.11221100%
4Corey KluberSP17.81522100%
5Stephen StrasburgSP27.42235100%
6Noah SyndergaardSP28.72334100%
7Madison BumgarnerSP29.82551100%
8Luis SeverinoSP33.82552100%
9Jacob deGromSP34.22640100%
10Zack GreinkeSP40.12657100%
11Carlos CarrascoSP44.93664100%
12Yu DarvishSP46.02355100%
13Carlos MartinezSP52.83876100%
14Justin VerlanderSP54.63890100%
15Aaron NolaSP56.13978100%
16James PaxtonSP60.04686100%
17Chris ArcherSP60.34676100%
18Robbie RaySP66.443127100%
19Dallas KeuchelSP67.14998100%
20Gerrit ColeSP82.542130100%
21Jose QuintanaSP82.862103100%
22Masahiro TanakaSP84.567116100%
23Shohei OhtaniSP88.658155100%
24David PriceSP89.847151100%
25Luis CastilloSP91.666110100%
26Jake ArrietaSP94.556117100%
27Lance McCullersSP97.343151100%
28Alex WoodSP98.663155100%
29Zack GodleySP101.765136100%
30Marcus StromanSP103.739167100%
31Sonny GraySP107.552175100%
32Kyle HendricksSP117.389176100%
33Jose BerriosSP121.883179100%
34Luke WeaverSP123.486169100%
35Michael FulmerSP124.292173100%
36Jon LesterSP126.8102157100%
37Jon GraySP132.878179100%
38Danny DuffySP139.7102175100%
39Johnny CuetoSP140.7100252100%
40Garrett RichardsSP153.7124194100%
41Rich HillSP154.783254100%
42Jameson TaillonSP157.1117237100%
43Drew PomeranzSP161.498238100%
44Jeff SamardzijaSP165.1120271100%
45Dylan BundySP171.8115297100%
46Chase AndersonSP173.7113242100%
47Trevor BauerSP174.3116231100%
48Danny SalazarSP179.213721795%
49Kenta MaedaSP180.197271100%
50Jacob FariaSP180.6147240100%
51Gio GonzalezSP182.7145213100%
52Taijuan WalkerSP184.510823995%
53Charlie MortonSP187.1130212100%
54Kevin GausmanSP192.5140271100%
55Sean ManaeaSP196.2142279100%
56Blake SnellSP199.9152253100%
57Patrick CorbinSP204.7161274100%
58Michael WachaSP210.614229595%
59Mike ClevingerSP215.513029789%
60Aaron SanchezSP218.9160283100%
61Cole HamelsSP221.714730095%
62Jordan MontgomerySP227.0168286100%
63Alex ReyesSP242.813428889%
64Julio TeheranSP242.918529695%
65Tanner RoarkSP252.120828695%
66Lance LynnSP254.417028189%
67Jake OdorizziSP261.720429853%
68Alex CobbSP265.116729395%
69Felix HernandezSP270.616029474%
70Carlos RodonSP278.513929774%
71Jimmy NelsonSP278.920630079%
72Ervin SantanaSP281.719528879%
73Dinelson LametSP284.818928168%
74Brad PeacockSP/RP301.115828058%
74Collin McHughSP303.121129863%
75J.A. HappSP309.321329958%
76Eduardo RodriguezSP318.221930063%
77Luiz GoharaSP319.319530058%
78Zach DaviesSP321.822829853%
79Steven MatzSP322.623426853%
80German MarquezSP324.521528347%
81Rick PorcelloSP324.721928553%
82Lucas GiolitoSP331.320528947%
83Mike FoltynewiczSP337.722027737%
84Miles MikolasSP340.821029242%
85Sean NewcombSP347.726329947%
86Ivan NovaSP350.525729342%
87Joe BiaginiSP, RP352.823729837%
88Joe MusgroveSP, RP354.723230037%

RP Rankings

RankingNamePositionConsensusHighLowPercent
1Kenley JansenRP55.14071100%
2Craig KimbrelRP62.44481100%
3Corey KnebelRP87.162116100%
4Aroldis ChapmanRP88.363123100%
5Roberto OsunaRP89.775119100%
6Felipe RiveroRP94.571127100%
7Ken GilesRP112.167157100%
8Edwin DiazRP112.482135100%
9Cody AllenRP120.693161100%
10Wade DavisRP121.272150100%
11Raisel IglesiasRP125.589148100%
12Sean DoolittleRP151.9101280100%
13Brad HandRP161.386245100%
14Alex ColomeRP161.9120183100%
15Mark MelanconRP167.6143197100%
16Hector NerisRP179.1139248100%
17Archie BradleyRP185.012425695%
18Jeurys FamiliaRP191.3141273100%
19Kelvin HerreraRP192.3128295100%
20Andrew MillerRP196.7150245100%
21Greg HollandRP213.315025895%
22Arodys VizcainoRP217.213828695%
23Blake TreinenRP227.415728295%
24Brandon MorrowRP260.512723563%
25Blake ParkerRP264.415426979%
26Dellin BetancesRP272.817927484%
27Chad GreenRP283.419728274%
28Brad BrachRP291.311924658%
29Brad PeacockSP/RP301.115828058%
30Cam BedrosianRP301.920729663%
31Carl EdwardsRP302.715628547%
32Zach BrittonRP310.219129663%
33Chris DevenskiRP310.223829868%
34Alex ClaudioRP311.621229558%
35Shane GreeneRP317.221929158%
36Fernando RodneyRP324.119327447%
37Josh HaderRP328.625430058%
38Kyle BarracloughRP330.523829053%
39Luke GregersonRP346.320929437%
40David RobertsonRP352.525329137%
41Joe BiaginiSP, RP352.823729837%
42Joe MusgroveSP, RP354.723230037%

Notes

  • Players who weren’t ranked on a list received a ranking of 400 for the purpose of creating the consensus ranking.
  • Brandon Morrow was not included in the template file that all the writers received (by accident). This is why he was not ranked on 7 lists. His consensus ranking among the 12 writers that ranked him was 179, which would put him around relievers Hector Neris and Archie Bradley.
  • Buster Posey was not included in the 1B rankings and is the only player who wasn’t included in all of his eligible positions. This is because no one is drafting Posey to play first base.
  • Similarly, Anthony Rizzo was not included in the 2B rankings because many leagues do not have him eligible to play there. He would be the #2 second basemen, just ahead of Jose Ramirez.
  • These lists were created solely for the 2018 season. Be sure to take that into account if you play in any type of keeper or dynasty league.
  • Writers who contributed (in alphabetical order): Alex Isherwood, Andrew Gould, Andrew Todd-Smith, Andy Patton, Austin Bristow, Ben Palmer, Ben Pernick, Grayson Blazek, Jake Bridges, Jay Dunbar, Jonathan Metzelaar, KV Singh, Kyle Bishop, Mark Weston, Max Posner, Michael Grennell, Myles Nelson, Nick Pollack, and Tim Acree.
Myles Nelson

Myles studied business marketing at Chapman University. He's best known for his work as a middle school basketball coach, where he revolutionized the game by getting his players to actually put the ball into the basket. Follow him @MylesNelsonPL for all things sports and occasional laughs.

    sdf

    Comments


    Paul

    Could you help me out with a keeper question? I’m in a 12 team H2H $260 budget league with OBP and slugging instead of average and penalties for strikeouts. A lot of the heavy hitters (Correa, turner, Judge, Stanton, Altuve, Blackmon, Arenado) are being kept which has me leaning towards keeping Kris Bryant for $35. That leaves me with two more options:

    Yu Darvish $19
    Khris Davis $17
    Carlos Carrasco $25
    Yasiel Puig $6
    Jose Berrios $7

    My heart is leaning Darvish and Puig for the prices but I’m conflicted with Darvish this year and like Carrasco better. Davis also finished as the 28th hitter last year in those settings and I’m just completely at odds with who to keep. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks!

    Myles Nelson

    Davis seems like a must-keep with those settings, and I personally would rather have Berrios and his upside than Puig, though I do love Puig. You could keep Darvish and Davis if you are cool spending that amount

    Chucky

    Hamilton #22, Deshields #55. I get that Billy is the premier base stealer in all the land, but Delino getting the leadoff slot, he has to move him up the ranks some, yes? no?

    Patrick

    I have a keeper question which I’m struggling with. 8×8 and categories are R, H, HR, RBI, SB, BB, AVG, OPS and W, CG, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, K/9, QS. 8 teams and 6 keepers. I’m keeping Turner, Correa, Machado, Freeman and Kershaw but not sure if I should keep Severino, Springer or Gary Sachez as my 6th.

    Leave a Comment


    Your email address will not be published.