The Hold Up 8/22: Ranking the Top 90 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Rank Change Pitcher
1
T1
- Adam Ottavino
2
- Giovanny Gallegos
3
- Ryan Pressly
4
+1 Zack Britton
5
+1 Will Harris
6
+1 Andrew Miller
7
+2 Tommy Kahnle
8
+8 Nick Anderson
9
+1 Pedro Baez
10
UR Edwin Diaz
11
T2
- Aaron Bummer
12
-4 Tony Watson
13
-1 Matt Barnes
14
-1 Ty Buttrey
15
+2 Craig Stammen
16
+2 Sergio Romo
17
-3 Sam Dyson
18
-3 Amir Garrett
19
- Pedro Strop
20
+8 Colin Poche
21
- Keone Kela
22
+24 Shane Greene
23
T3
-3 Yusmeiro Petit
24
- Cam Bedrosian
25
+1 Michael Lorenzen
26
-3 Yoan Lopez
27
+33 Justin Wilson
28
-6 Derek Law
29
- Chris Martin
30
- John Gant
31
- Nick Wittgren
32
-7 Anthony Swarzak
33
+1 David Phelps
34
-1 Shawn Kelley
35
UR Luke Jackson
36
+44 Mike Morin
37
- Hunter Strickland
38
+14 Andres Munoz
39
+18 Joe Kelly
40
+4 Blake Treinen
41
-5 Oliver Perez
42
-10 Yoshihisa Hirano
43
-8 Reyes Moronta
44
-5 Chaz Roe
45
T4
-7 Jake Diekman
46
-3 Diego Castillo
47
-7 Kyle Ryan
48
UR Steve Cishek
49
-4 John Brebbia
50
-3 Joakim Soria
51
-10 Nick Goody
52
+10 Trevor May
53
-3 Chad Green
54
-5 Tim Mayza
55
- Andrew Chafin
56
-2 Adam Kolarek
57
+1 Trey Wingenter
58
-2 Matt Albers
59
+7 Jose Alvarez
60
-9 Adam Cimber
61
UR Matt Magill
62
UR Carlos Estevez
63
UR Jairo Diaz
64
- Evan Marshall
65
+8 Buck Farmer
66
-18 Sean Newcomb
67
T5
+3 Fernando Rodney
68
+1 Tyler Duffey
69
-6 Jake McGee
70
+2 Wander Suero
71
+18 Jimmy Cordero
72
-19 Jeremy Jeffress
73
UR A.J. Puk
74
-7 Ryne Harper
75
+11 Alex Claudio
76
+2 Lou Trivino
77
+2 Michael Feliz
78
+3 Marcus Walden
79
-5 Junior Guerra
80
-5 Jerry Blevins
81
+1 Emmanuel Clase
82
+1 Tyler Clippard
83
+4 Scott Barlow
84
+4 Oliver Drake
85
UR Kevin Ginkel
86
UR Matt Strahm
87
UR Sam Tuivailala
88
-3 Ryan Buchter
89
+1 Rafael Montero
90
-31 Justin Shafer
  • The Mets bullpen has been in turmoil as of late, with Seth Lugo replacing Edwin Diaz in the closer role for now. The team has stated it wants to get Diaz out of high-leverage situations in order to get him right, which makes sense for now. Right in the middle of a playoff race, and with few relievers they can truly count on, the team will need Diaz to get back on the right track as soon as possible. He was fine in two innings pitched this week (one hit, a walk, and three strikeouts), so hopefully that’s a small step in the right direction. The other reliever in New York surging up the depth chart is Justin Wilson, who could mix into some ninth inning situations with Lugo. He’s been a sneaky contributor in ERA, strikeouts, and holds this season.
  • Another NL East bullpen that is trying to figure itself out is based out of Atlanta, with Mark Melancon currently the favorite for saves. That could change in a week, as both Shane Greene and Luke Jackson pitched well this week, but for now, the three are interesting last reliever on the roster types for those in SV/HLD leagues.
  • Mike Morin is the next man up in the Phillies’ quest to find a setup man to work in front of Hector Neris, with the results encouraging for the time being. He hasn’t allowed a walk in more than a month and now has four holds over the past two weeks. Andres Munoz continues to flash his immense potential and this week was able to pick up two holds. Here’s to hoping he carves out a setup role in front of Craig Stammen and Kirby Yates the rest of the season. While he hasn’t been contributing in the holds department quite yet, Joe Kelly has quietly figured things out and is currently on pace to have the best season of his career. Over the last two months, he holds a 23:4 K/BB rate while allowing just 12 hits over 17.1 innings.
Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

sdf

Comments


JK

Hey Rick,

In a saves / holds league, would A.J. Puk be a wise investment for sneaky holds since he has SP eligibility only? Do you think he will stick in that high leverage holds role?

Thx

Rick Graham

Little tentative on him at the moment but last night’s usage was certainly promising. Given his SP eligibility, maybe he deserves a bump but I want to see how things play out for a week or so.

Jim

How is Nick Anderson climbing the ranks when he is getting virtually no Hold chances? Ratios, yes. They are great. But this is the ‘Hold Up’ and with 2 Holds over the past month, that is below replacement level. (Actually he had one last night, so that’s 3 in 30 days.)
What am I missing? Isn’t it safer to own a lower tier Closer like Melancon atm?

Rick Graham

He is the clear cut top set up man there, working the 8th inning for almost all of Pagan’s save chances since he was dealt. The hold totals are bad luck and he should see a 2 maybe 3 hold week ahead. For now, I’ll take the elite ratios and K’s while waiting for the holds to come.

Rick Graham

Only three RP’s have 6 or more holds since August 1. Gallegos has 3 (1 more than Ottavino) which ranks 15th and provides elite ratios and K totals. It’s too hard to predict holds so I can only base these rankings on talent, performance and role.

Orange WHIPs

Yeah, I mean I roster him everywhere and he’s definitely helpful, but I just don’t see a guy with 12 Holds on the season (and in his career total), a decent sample size, as the second-most valuable Hold RP. Especially with such a short track record of MLB success. I’d slate him in the low teens.

Orange WHIPs

I’m concerned about Pedro Baez’s peripherals. The opportunities should be there, but he’s not pitching very well.

It’s down to Baez, Duffey, and Bummer for my last RP slot down the stretch where I need ratios, Ks and SV+HLDs. Really can’t decide which – Duffey is pitching great and seems like his role is increasing with a cakewalk schedule for the Twins, Baez should get the most opportunities but is pitching poorly, and Bummer has the best ratios on the season but lacks Ks and is on a garbage team. Thoughts?

Leave a Comment


Your email address will not be published.