Sit/Start Week 23: Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups From 9/10 – 9/16

Here's a giant table of every starting pitcher matchup for Week 23, telling you which pitchers should get in your lineup or stick on your bench.

Every Sunday here at Pitcher List, I review all expected starting pitcher matchups for the week ahead. There are three labels: StartMaybe, and Sit. Outings marked with a Maybe are circumstantial and dependent on your needs in a standard 5×5 Wins 12-teamer, while the other two are self-explanatory. Feel free to question my designations in the comments and we’ll dive into it together.

Here’s the massive table containing every Week 23 start from 9/10 – 9/16:

Note: These matchups are subject to change.

DateGameAway PitcherSit / StartHome PitcherSit / Start
9/10MIL vs CHCWade MileySitJon LesterStart
9/10LAD vs CINAlex WoodStartCody ReedSit
9/10ARI vs COLZack GodleyMaybeGerman MarquezStart
9/10HOU vs DETJustin VerlanderStartFrancisco LirianoSit
9/10CHW vs KCRLucas GiolitoStartJakob JunisStart
9/10TEX vs LAAMike MinorStartJaime BarriaMaybe
9/10NYY vs MINJ.A. HappStartKyle GibsonSit
9/10MIA vs NYMJeff BrighamSitJacob DegromStart
9/10WSH vs PHIErick FeddeSitJake ArrietaStart
9/10ATL vs SFGSean NewcombSitDereck RodriguezStart
9/10PIT vs STLTrevor WilliamsMaybeAdam WainwrightSit
9/10CLE vs TBRCorey KluberStartDiego CastilloSit
9/11OAK vs BALMike FiersStartAlex CobbSit
9/11TOR vs BOSRyan BoruckiSitChris SaleStart
9/11MIL vs CHCJhoulys ChacinSitJose QuintanaStart
9/11LAD vs CINHyun-Jin RyuStartLuis CastilloStart
9/11ARI vs COLZack GreinkeStartAntonio SenzatelaSit
9/11HOU vs DETFramber ValdezSitJordan ZimmermannSit
9/11CHW vs KCR???Sit???Sit
9/11TEX vs LAAAdrian SampsonSitBullpen?Sit
9/11NYY vs MINSonny GraySitKohl StewartSit
9/11MIA vs NYMJose UrenaMaybeJason VargasSit
9/11WSH vs PHITanner RoarkMaybeNick PivettaMaybe
9/11SDP vs SEABryan MitchellSitMarco GonzalesSit
9/11ATL vs SFGMike FoltynewiczStartAndrew SuarezSit
9/11PIT vs STLJoe MusgroveMaybeMiles MikolasStart
9/11CLE vs TBRShane BieberMaybeTyler GlasnowMaybe
9/12OAK vs BALBullpen?SitAndrew CashnerSit
9/12TOR vs BOSAaron SanchezSitDavid PriceStart
9/12MIL vs CHCChase AndersonSitKyle HendricksStart
9/12LAD vs CINRoss StriplingMaybeAnthony DesclafaniSit
9/12ARI vs COLPatrick CorbinStartJon GrayMaybe
9/12HOU vs DETGerrit ColeStartDaniel NorrisSit
9/12CHW vs KCRCarlos RodonStartBrad KellerSit
9/12TEX vs LAAYovani GallardoSitFelix PenaMaybe
9/12NYY vs MINLuis SeverinoStartJake OdorizziSit
9/12MIA vs NYMTrevor RichardsStartZack WheelerStart
9/12WSH vs PHIStephen StrasburgStartAaron NolaStart
9/12SDP vs SEAJoey LucchesiStartWade LeblancStart
9/12ATL vs SFGAnibal SanchezStartDerek HollandStart
9/12PIT vs STLJameson TaillonStartAustin GomberMaybe
9/12CLE vs TBRCarlos CarrascoStartBlake SnellStart
9/13OAK vs BALChris Bassitt?SitDylan BundySit
9/13TOR vs BOSSam GaviglioSitEduardo RodriguezStart
9/13ARI vs COLClay BuchholzMaybeKyle FreelandStart
9/13MIN vs KCRStephen GonsalvesSitHeath FillmyerSit
9/13SEA vs LAAJames PaxtonStartMatt ShoemakerSit
9/13MIA vs NYMSandy AlcantaraMaybeSteven MatzStart
9/13LAD vs STLClayton KershawStartJack FlahertyStart
9/13CHC vs WSHCole HamelsStartJoe RossSit
9/14WSH vs ATLMax ScherzerStartKevin GausmanMaybe
9/14CHW vs BALJames ShieldsSitDavid HessSit
9/14NYM vs BOSNoah SyndergaardStartBrian JohnsonSit
9/14CIN vs CHCMatt HarveySitMike MontgomerySit
9/14DET vs CLEMatthew BoydSitAdam PlutkoSit
9/14ARI vs HOURobbie RayStartCharlie MortonStart
9/14MIN vs KCRJose BerriosStartJorge LopezSit
9/14SEA vs LAAMike LeakeMaybeAndrew HeaneyMaybe
9/14PIT vs MILChris ArcherMaybeGio GonzalezMaybe
9/14TOR vs NYYMarco EstradaSitMasahiro TanakaStart
9/14MIA vs PHIWei-Yin ChenMaybeZach EflinMaybe
9/14TEX vs SDPYohander MendezSitEric LauerSit
9/14COL vs SFGTyler AndersonMaybeChris StrattonSit
9/14LAD vs STLWalker BuehlerStartJohn GantMaybe
9/14OAK vs TBREdwin JacksonSitBullpenSit
9/15WSH vs ATLErick FeddeSitJulio TeheranMaybe
9/15CHW vs BALReynaldo LopezMaybeJosh Rogers?Sit
9/15NYM vs BOSJacob DegromStartRick PorcelloStart
9/15CIN vs CHCTyler MahleSitJose QuintanaStart
9/15DET vs CLEMichael FulmerMaybeMike ClevingerStart
9/15ARI vs HOUZack GodleyMaybeDallas KeuchelStart
9/15MIN vs KCRZack LittellSitIan KennedySit
9/15SEA vs LAAFelix HernandezSitJaime BarriaMaybe
9/15PIT vs MILIvan NovaMaybeZach DaviesMaybe
9/15TOR vs NYYSean-Reid FoleySitLance LynnMaybe
9/15MIA vs PHIJeff BrighamSitVince VelasquezMaybe
9/15TEX vs SDPAriel JuradoSitBrett KennedySit
9/15COL vs SFGGerman MarquezStartMadison BumgarnerStart
9/15LAD vs STLRich HillStartAdam WainwrightSit
9/15OAK vs TBRTrevor CahillSitBullpenSit
9/16WSH vs ATLTanner RoarkMaybeSean Newcomb?Sit
9/16CHW vs BALLucas GiolitoStartAlex CobbSit
9/16NYM vs BOSJason VargasSitChris SaleStart
9/16CIN vs CHCCody ReedSitKyle HendricksStart
9/16DET vs CLEFrancisco LirianoSitCorey KluberStart
9/16ARI vs HOUZack GreinkeStartJustin VerlanderStart
9/16MIN vs KCRKyle GibsonStartJakob JunisMaybe
9/16SEA vs LAAMarco GonzalesSitBullpen?Sit
9/16PIT vs MILTrevor WilliamsMaybeWade MileyMaybe
9/16TOR vs NYYThomas PannoneSitCC SabathiaStart
9/16MIA vs PHIJose UrenaMaybeJake ArrietaStart
9/16TEX vs SDPMike MinorStartRobbie ErlinSit
9/16COL vs SFGAntonio SenzatelaSitDereck RodriguezStart
9/16LAD vs STLAlex WoodStartMiles MikolasStart
9/16OAK vs TBRMike FiersMaybeDiego CastilloSit

Nick Pollack

Founder of Pitcher List. Rotographs contributor. Worked with CBS Sports, Grantland, Washington Post, and SB Nation. Former pitching coach and Brandeis alum.

  • Avatar BJ says:

    Nick, great stuff as always. Would appreciate your help locking in my final pitching spots in a H2H points league going into Week 1 playoffs. Need 2 of these 3 “Maybe”s:
    Gant vs. LAD
    Tyler Anderson @ SF
    Jose Urena @ NYM, @ PHI
    Right now I’m leaning Urena and Gant, Anderson has been too inconsistent even though SF vs. Stratton sounds cushy. Urena is the worst of the three, but I have no other two start pitchers going. I don’t have to start him @ Philly though. Any thoughts? Thanks in advance.

    • Nick Pollack Nick Pollack says:

      Urena since it’s two starts.

      I’m not a big fan of Gant, honestly, and think you’re better off with Tyler as the Giants are terribly weak.

  • Avatar Phil says:

    Nick, love this. Can’t tell you how helpful it is.

    In a H2H categories league, would you be any more willing to roll the dice with some of the maybes or even sits like Godley, Gibson, or Pivetta if your opponent was rolling out “weaker” sits like Newcomb, Fedde, or Suarez?

    Thanks!

  • Avatar Ed says:

    With Matz pushed to face Boston, is he a sit now? Start Pivetta over Matz?

  • Avatar John Connors says:

    Would you rather start Veldez against Detroit or Pena against Texas. Where innings pitched and going for the W really Matter.

  • Avatar Pitcher List Fan says:

    Rotoworld is showing Chen starting vs the Mets on Thursday. Worth starting if he does end up going against the mets?

  • Avatar Al says:

    what about cc or vince velasquez today?

  • Avatar David says:

    I’ve been looking for your 9/17 – 9/23 Sit or Start list? Was 9/10 – 9/16 your last one? My Yahoo fantasy league is still going on for possibly this week….and next if I make the Championship. Either way thanks for your great work all season!

  • Account / Login
    >