Closing Time 4/23: Ranking the Top 30 Closers Every Tuesday

Rank Change Pitcher Previous Next In Line
Edwin Diaz 1 Jeurys Familia
Kenley Jansen 2 Pedro Baez
Blake Treinen 4 Lou Trivino
Kirby Yates 7 Craig Stammen
Aroldis Chapman 5 Zack Britton
Josh Hader 3 Jeremy Jeffress
Roberto Osuna 8 Ryan Pressly
Felipe Vazquez 9 Keone Kela
Sean Doolittle 6 Kyle Barraclough
Brad Hand 11 Nick Wittgren
Jose Leclerc 10 Shawn Kelley
Jose Alvarado 12 Diego Castillo
Will Smith 13 Sam Dyson
Ken Giles 14 Joe Biagini
Jordan Hicks 19 Andrew Miller
Raisel Iglesias 18 David Hernandez
Wade Davis 17 Scott Oberg
A. J. Minter 15 Luke Jackson
Ryan Brasier 16 Matt Barnes
Pedro Strop 25 Steve Cishek
Shane Greene 21 Joe Jimenez
Greg Holland 23 Archie Bradley
Alex Colome 22 Kelvin Herrera
Cody Allen 20 Ty Buttrey
Hector Neris 27 Pat Neshek
Blake Parker 26 Taylor Rogers
Anthony Swarzak 24 Roenis Elias
Sergio Romo 28 Adam Conley
Mychal Givens 29 Miguel Castro
Wily Peralta 30 Ian Kennedy

Light pink row designates Closer By Committee

  • Josh Hader’s bump down the list is less to do with the walks or HR’s he allowed this weekend, and mostly because of Jeremy Jeffress‘s presence. While Hader is still going to get his saves, Jeffress will likely cut into his chances and we’ll probably see close to a 50/50, 60/40 split assuming both are healthy.
  • I’m still holding out hope for Jose Leclerc to turn things around here, and it’s great to see the vote of confidence from Chris Woodward. He thinks Leclerc is tipping his pitches, which I’m not really sure how that explains the 4 walks Sunday, but at least we know they are going to do everything to get him right. There’s certainly a chance that 2018 was the anomaly in Leclerc’s career and the command woes from his past will continue to plague him. But I still have faith that we’ll see last year’s version of Leclerc soon, so hang in there for now, as there’s potentially a huge payoff for those who hold or buy low.
  • A.J. Minter does have the role and has little to no competition, but he just doesn’t seem right. His stuff is flat, he’s not locating anything and certainly doesn’t look like the pitcher we saw over his first 76+ innings. I know this is beating a dead horse, but the Braves have to be the frontrunner for Craig Kimbrel, right?
  • I’m still in on Ryan Brasier in most leagues despite the fact that he’s only seeing about 70+% of the save opportunities. This week proved that fraction can still work with Brasier picking up 3 saves to Matt Barnes‘ 1.
  • Brandon Morrow is out indefinitely after having a setback in his rehab, and honestly, I wouldn’t be surprised if we don’t see him till after the All-Star break if not later (or ever, with his history). Pedro Strop hasn’t been great, but he’s held it together more or less to start the season and now has an opportunity to keep the job over the long haul.
  • Cody Allen’s job security has to be on thin ice after his previous 4 outings, and with him only signed to a one-year deal, it’s easy enough for the Angels to move on from him. Despite Ty Buttrey’s use, he should be the next in line after he finished 2018 as the teams closer. Kenyan Middleton is another name to monitor this summer as he works his way back from Tommy John.
  • Hector Neris was actually able to secure 2 saves this week, a rare feat for a Phillies reliever. He’s worth an add if you are searching for extra saves, but I wouldn’t get my hopes up with Gabe Kapler calling the shots.
  • Despite Tyler Rogers earning two saves, I still think the Twins closer situation is in the same position as it has been for weeks now. Blake Parker should still see most of the chances but Rogers will mix in when the opposing team has a left-handed majority due up.
  • Anthony Swarzak and Roenis Elias may be in more of a timeshare than previously expected. I’d still prefer Swarzak, but Elias is definitely on the radar in deeper, 15+ team leagues.
Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.




grade the trade: Alvarado for Paul DeJong

14 team H2H categories with saves and holds each separate category (yates, doolittle, betances, and moronta remaining RPs)

Rick Graham

I like it. Always down for cashing in a RP for a position player. I’d still be on the lookout for RP help through waivers though.


Offered Laureano for my Brasier in a 12 team mixed redraft. I already have Alvarado/Castillo, Raisel, and Parker as closers.

You think Laureano still has the upside to make this deal worth it? Thanks!


Would you drop either A. Miller or S. Dominguez for a speculative add of C. Kimbrel? Is Matt Barnes worth adding over them? 12 team H2H w/ traditional scoring. Leclerc is only full-time closer.

Perfect Game

Leclerc’s K% and K/9 are down and his control issues are reflected in his BB/9 and BB% and mirror his previous years’ performance before his “breakout”. Last year was a fluke.

Rick Graham

Its only been 8 innings so far.

Maybe last year was a fluke but I’ll judge him more off his last 57.2 IP (2018) compared to his previous 60.2 IP (2016-2017). Only a 4 inning difference in sample size and typically we see these types of improvements stick.

David J Theriault

For the Angels, I agree that Buttrey is the best option for the Angels, but he’s been used in the fireman role and it’s Robles who has usually pitched the 9th. Plus Robles already has that custom Undertaker video they show for his entrance song.

Rick Graham

Haha fair point on the entrance video/song. You may be right that Robles is the true next in line, but I expect Buttrey to get in the mix their at some point this year.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.