Keep or Kut – Pete (@PeteBBaseball) and Chad (@chadyoung) discuss players whose seasons just aren’t that easy to interpret and who are therefore tough to value for the future. With keeper decisions around the corner, plus draft season coming, these are the guys we expect to keep us up at night.
Join Pitcher List Plus and get an ad-free website and access to the Pitcher List Discord community, while supporting the podcast.
2:02 – Plan to discuss players whose value is hard to lock down for next year.
2:55 – Kris Bryant, the Coors Field power outage, and 181 surprisingly good PA.
11:43 – The Trevor Story Roller Coaster.
17:37 – Is Jack Flaherty still living off 2019?
27:31 – Lucas Giolito’s awful season.
38:48 – Are we worried about Juan Soto?
44:47 – Nick Castellanos misses home.
52:51 – Maybe Frankie Montas does, too.
59:18 – Paul Goldschmidt re-enters the 1B top 5.
1:02:50 – Is Nate Lowe far behind?
1:05:07 – Alex Bregman isn’t in the top five, but who is ahead of him? Bobby Witt Jr.? Gunnar Henderson?