One final point: At this stage of the season, specific needs and schedules mean everything! While I may rank one player a tier or two higher than another, there are more reasons now than ever to ignore such a gap in the late tiers if you’re after a specific stat.
- Matt Olson remains outside the top-15 first baseman despite playing every day this season. The 29 home runs and 95 RBI are all well and good, but a .234 batting average just doesn’t cut it. Olson is also sputtering to the finish line with a 31.6% strikeout rate in September and a putrid 28 wRC+.
- Speaking of old Dodger hitters who got off to a slow start and who will be free agents in 2023, Justin Turner continues to do Justin Turner things. The home run power hasn’t quite been there, though the four he’s hit this month are more than he hit in any other month, and Turner has an impressive 181 wRC+ since June 30. It’s hard to say what will happen to Turner this offseason, but as long as he’s a Dodger, he’ll have fantasy relevance.
- Luis Robert isn’t returning this season, and I have no idea where to rank him for 2023 due to the injuries, so I’m leaving him right here. Honestly, this feels about right when you look at the extreme risk.
- I’d love to see Nick Castellanos put on a fireworks show from now to the end of the season. I was high on him during the draft season but it just hasn’t gone Castellanos’s way in 2022.
- Corbin Carroll looks every bit like the top prospect we were promised, and his placement on this list directly ahead of Wander Franco is very intentional.
- Taylor Ward’s .333/.398/.531 line with four home runs and two steals in September have me back on board, baby. Hitting fourth behind Shohei Ohtani and Trout is a good place to be.
- Triston Casas has three home runs and a 30.8% walk rate over his last six games with just a 15.4% strikeout rate. Whoa. I mentioned in last week’s Taxi Squad that the power hadn’t really shown up yet, but here it is.
- That Elvis Andrus ride was fun while it lasted.
And now, once again, it’s time for the Hitter List:
Saw your note about Muncy being a free agent after the season and that he could be leaving the Dodgers. I thought Muncy signed an extension with the Dodgers a month or so ago.
Thanks for the heads up! Totally forgot about that news. I’ll make that correction – Dodgerland is exactly where we’d want Muncy to be anyway.
Are you going to do a hitter list for the postseason as well? That would be awesome!
Unfortunately no, but the Too Early Hitter List will publish in about 2 weeks.