Closing Time 6/26: Ranking the Top 30 Closers Every Tuesday

Rank Change Pitcher Previous Next In Line
Kenley Jansen 1 Josh Fields
Aroldis Chapman 2 Dellin Betances
Craig Kimbrel 4 Joe Kelly
Edwin Diaz 3 Alex Colome
Blake Treinen 6 Lou Trivino
Sean Doolittle 5 Kelvin Herrera
Corey Knebel 11 Josh Hader
Brad Hand 7 Kirby Yates
Cody Allen 10 Neil Ramirez
Seranthony Dominguez 8 Hector Neris
Keone Kela 15 Alex Claudio
Zack Britton 12 Brad Brach
Bud Norris 14 Jordan Hicks
Felipe Vazquez 17 Michael Feliz
Wade Davis 16 Adam Ottavino
Raisel Iglesias 19 Jared Hughes
Brad Boxberger 18 Archie Bradley
Kyle Barraclough 23 Drew Steckenrider
Blake Parker 24 Justin Anderson
Ken Giles UR Hector Rondon
Jeurys Familia 21 Robert Gsellman
Fernando Rodney 26 Addison Reed
Joakim Soria 25 Bruce Rondon
Shane Greene 22 Joe Jimenez
Sam Dyson UR Mark Melancon
Sergio Romo 30 Chaz Roe
Ryan Tepera 27 Seung-hwan Oh
A. J. Minter UR Dan Winkler
Steve Cishek UR Pedro Strop
Wily Peralta UR Brandon Maurer

Light pink row designates Closer By Committee


It may look like a four-man committee in San Francisco right now, but eventually, as delicate as they are treating him, Mark Melancon will get his job back, the one that the team is paying him $62 million to do. It sounds like it is just a matter of when Melancon is able to pitch consecutive days, however, Bruce Bochy is still unsure of when that will be, leaving the situation still in flux. For now, expect Sam Dyson and Tony Watson to see the bulk of the 8th/9th work with Melancon sprinkled in. At some point though, hopefully, pre-All-Star break, we should see Melancon re-inserted as the team’s closers.

  • In other committee news, the Astros situation still remains fluid, although it looked like Ken Giles was at least given an opportunity to take his job back from Hector Rondon. He earned a loss after allowing a run in the 9th during a tie game Friday and is still terrible in non-save situations and great in save situations (and 27/3 K/BB to back it up). It’s still somewhat unclear what the Mets are looking to do with their closer situation since they have only had a grand total of 3 saves the past month with two going to Robert Gsellman and one to Jeurys Familia. Ryan Tepera has a little over a month left as the Blue Jays closer. Dave Cherman did a great job of laying out how to handle the Roberto Osuna situation here. For the time being, it’s probably best you just stay away from all Royals relievers.
  • We had a slew of closer injuries this past week, with Hunter Strickland, Brandon Morrow, and Arodys Vizcaino all hitting the DL. We talked about the Giants situation in the opener and that seems to be the most significant injury of the three. Morrow is already back throwing and could return after the minimum amount of DL time which would see him return this weekend. I still think the team plays it safe, with a return next Tuesday more likely. Vizcaino’s shoulder injury, on the other hand, is a bit trickier, but it does seem likely to be a short-term thing. Steve Cishek, Pedro Strop, A.J. Minter and Dan Winkler are still worth adds in the short term if you have roster space.
  • Kenley Jansen, Blake Treinen, Sean Doolittle, Keone Kela and Raisel Iglesias all tied for the weekly lead in saves with 4. Kela has been great since his May 1st implosion against the Indians and has allowed only 4 runs over 18 innings to go with 13 saves and a 21/7 K/BB ratio.
Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.




Aside from Friday, Britton has gotten through his outings fine, but he doesn’t seem to have his best stuff out there. Does he just need to shake some rust off, or might he be a liability?

Rick Graham

Mostly rust, but we have to recognize that what he did in 2016 won’t happen again. He won’t be lights out every single time he pitches, but he should still be a fairly reliable reliever with an ERA around 2 and WHIP around 1.

Rick Graham

He’s looked more like his 2017 self the past few weeks, striking out 2 batters an inning and has his WHIP at .96 over he past month. He has more upside than Allen.

Perfect Game

So you’re not concerned about his role going forward and the Brew Crew using a closer by committee or match-up approach? Should I try to trade away Allen for Knebel?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.