Pitcher List’s Staff Consensus Top 300 Overall Players

It’s time for some rankings! 19 of our writers sent in their personal top 300 rankings, and we’ve combined them all to give to you the consensus rankings for our site. Use these rankings to help you gauge trade value, to help you create your own draft rankings, and to see how players are valued by a large group of industry writers.

These rankings were made with H2H 5×5 12-teamers in mind. These were also done prior to some of the most recent news, such as Mike Moustakas signing with the Royals and Marcus Stroman’s shoulder inflammation.

Overall Top 300

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Mike Trout	OF	1.1	1	2	100%
2	Jose Altuve	2B	1.9	1	2	100%
3	Nolan Arenado	3B	4.1	3	7	100%
4	Mookie Betts	OF	5.9	3	10	100%
5	Bryce Harper	OF	6.3	3	13	100%
6	Trea Turner	SS	6.3	3	14	100%
7	Paul Goldschmidt	1B	7.1	3	14	100%
8	Charlie Blackmon	OF	9.6	3	20	100%
9	Giancarlo Stanton	OF	9.6	6	24	100%
10	Clayton Kershaw	SP	9.8	5	17	100%
11	Carlos Correa	SS	9.9	3	15	100%
12	Kris Bryant	3B	11.5	6	22	100%
13	Joey Votto	1B	14.2	6	20	100%
14	Max Scherzer	SP	15.3	11	20	100%
15	Chris Sale	SP	16.1	12	21	100%
16	Manny Machado	3B	16.3	11	24	100%
17	Francisco Lindor	SS	16.5	8	24	100%
18	Corey Kluber	SP	17.8	15	22	100%
19	Freddie Freeman	1B	19.4	12	34	100%
20	Aaron Judge	OF	19.9	12	30	100%
21	Anthony Rizzo	1B	20.1	14	24	100%
22	J.D. Martinez	OF	22.9	17	31	100%
23	Jose Ramirez	2B, 3B	23.7	18	37	100%
24	George Springer	OF	25.5	22	35	100%
25	Josh Donaldson	3B	26.5	11	36	100%
26	Corey Seager	SS	26.6	15	42	100%
27	Stephen Strasburg	SP	27.4	22	35	100%
28	Cody Bellinger	1B, OF	28.6	20	62	100%
29	Noah Syndergaard	SP	28.7	23	34	100%
30	Madison Bumgarner	SP	29.8	25	51	100%
31	Gary Sanchez	C	31.8	21	46	100%
32	Brian Dozier	2B	33.5	29	40	100%
33	Luis Severino	SP	33.8	25	52	100%
34	Jacob deGrom	SP	34.2	26	40	100%
35	Alex Bregman	3B, SS	39.0	26	55	100%
36	Jose Abreu	1B	39.8	29	55	100%
37	Zack Greinke	SP	40.1	26	57	100%
38	Dee Gordon	2B	40.3	31	67	100%
39	Anthony Rendon	3B	41.0	30	60	100%
40	Rhys Hoskins	1B, OF	43.9	27	103	100%
41	Carlos Carrasco	SP	44.9	36	64	100%
42	Christian Yelich	OF	45.4	38	64	100%
43	Yu Darvish	SP	46.0	23	55	100%
44	Justin Upton	OF	46.1	30	73	100%
45	Marcell Ozuna	OF	46.5	32	74	100%
46	Justin Turner	3B	47.8	29	72	100%
47	Andrew Benintendi	OF	50.2	40	76	100%
48	Carlos Martinez	SP	52.8	38	76	100%
49	Daniel Murphy	2B	53.2	40	73	100%
50	Justin Verlander	SP	54.6	38	90	100%
51	Kenley Jansen	RP	55.1	40	71	100%
52	Nelson Cruz	DH	56.1	28	116	100%
53	Aaron Nola	SP	56.1	39	78	100%
54	Starling Marte	OF	58.2	36	95	100%
55	James Paxton	SP	60.0	46	86	100%
56	Chris Archer	SP	60.3	46	76	100%
57	Wil Myers	1B	60.5	36	88	100%
58	Byron Buxton	OF	61.8	43	85	100%
59	Craig Kimbrel	RP	62.4	44	81	100%
60	Elvis Andrus	SS	62.6	41	80	100%
61	Tommy Pham	OF	63.9	53	143	100%
62	Edwin Encarnacion	1B	65.1	35	127	100%
63	Robbie Ray	SP	66.4	43	127	100%
64	Dallas Keuchel	SP	67.1	49	98	100%
65	Willson Contreras	C	68.0	45	88	100%
66	Buster Posey	C	73.6	51	94	100%
67	Jean Segura	SS	73.8	52	104	100%
68	Robinson Cano	2B	74.2	53	100	100%
69	Yoenis Cespedes	OF	74.6	60	97	100%
70	A.J. Pollock	OF	74.7	42	101	100%
71	Whit Merrifield	2B	75.1	39	141	100%
72	Eric Hosmer	1B	77.0	57	115	100%
73	Xander Bogaerts	SS	81.4	52	108	100%
74	Andrew McCutchen	OF	82.3	64	105	100%
75	Gerrit Cole	SP	82.5	42	130	100%
76	Lorenzo Cain	OF	82.7	60	104	100%
77	Jose Quintana	SP	82.8	62	103	100%
78	Billy Hamilton	OF	83.8	61	182	100%
79	Masahiro Tanaka	SP	84.5	67	116	100%
80	Domingo Santana	OF	85.5	59	138	100%
81	Corey Knebel	RP	87.1	62	116	100%
82	Aroldis Chapman	RP	88.3	63	123	100%
83	Shohei Ohtani	SP	88.6	58	155	100%
84	Khris Davis	OF	88.6	46	166	100%
85	Roberto Osuna	RP	89.7	75	119	100%
86	David Price	SP	89.8	47	151	100%
87	Luis Castillo	SP	91.6	66	110	100%
88	Jonathan Schoop	2B	91.9	48	146	100%
89	Ryan Braun	OF	92.9	74	138	100%
90	Jake Arrieta	SP	94.5	56	117	100%
91	Felipe Rivero	RP	94.5	71	127	100%
92	Lance McCullers	SP	97.3	43	151	100%
93	Yasiel Puig	OF	97.9	57	163	100%
94	Alex Wood	SP	98.6	63	155	100%
95	Justin Smoak	1B	99.3	70	143	100%
96	Zack Godley	SP	101.7	65	136	100%
97	Jake Lamb	3B	101.9	63	175	95%
98	Travis Shaw	3B	102.6	72	195	100%
99	Kyle Seager	3B	103.6	64	165	100%
100	Marcus Stroman	SP	103.7	39	167	100%
101	Miguel Sano	3B	105.3	59	166	100%
102	Miguel Cabrera	1B	105.6	63	192	100%
103	Sonny Gray	SP	107.5	52	175	100%
104	Salvador Perez	C	109.2	77	190	100%
105	Ender Inciarte	OF	111.1	83	152	100%
106	Ken Giles	RP	112.1	67	157	100%
107	Rougned Odor	2B	112.4	77	200	100%
108	Edwin Diaz	RP	112.4	82	135	100%
109	Adam Eaton	OF	112.5	90	166	100%
110	Chris Taylor	2B, OF	115.6	78	154	100%
111	Matt Carpenter	1B	116.7	69	187	100%
112	Kyle Hendricks	SP	117.3	89	176	100%
113	Joey Gallo	1B, 3B	117.4	85	184	100%
114	J.T. Realmuto	C	119.3	80	208	100%
115	Cody Allen	RP	120.6	93	161	100%
116	Wade Davis	RP	121.2	72	150	100%
117	Yoan Moncada	2B	121.4	70	166	100%
118	Jose Berrios	SP	121.8	83	179	100%
119	Rafael Devers	3B	122.1	79	184	100%
120	Luke Weaver	SP	123.4	86	169	100%
121	Adrian Beltre	3B	123.9	59	223	100%
122	Michael Fulmer	SP	124.2	92	173	100%
123	Raisel Iglesias	RP	125.5	89	148	100%
124	Jon Lester	SP	126.8	102	157	100%
125	D.J. LeMahieu	2B	127.5	89	207	100%
126	Matt Olson	1B	130.7	65	182	100%
127	Jon Gray	SP	132.8	78	179	100%
128	Mike Moustakas	3B	133.3	87	270	100%
129	Greg Bird	1B	134.1	95	185	100%
130	Gregory Polanco	OF	134.7	100	171	100%
131	Carlos Santana	1B	135.2	101	169	100%
132	Nick Castellanos	3B	136.9	96	176	100%
133	Danny Duffy	SP	139.7	102	175	100%
134	Johnny Cueto	SP	140.7	100	252	100%
135	Eddie Rosario	OF	141.2	66	223	100%
136	Manuel Margot	OF	142.4	105	256	100%
137	Michael Conforto	OF	142.8	85	191	100%
138	Didi Gregorius	SS	143.2	86	187	100%
139	Trevor Story	SS	147.5	91	217	100%
140	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, SS, OF	148.1	117	197	100%
141	Sean Doolittle	RP	151.9	101	280	100%
142	Adam Jones	OF	152.5	90	219	100%
143	Ryan Zimmerman	1B	153.6	80	217	100%
144	Garrett Richards	SP	153.7	124	194	100%
145	Eduardo Nunez	2B, 3B, OF	154.3	90	202	100%
146	Rich Hill	SP	154.7	83	254	100%
147	Nomar Mazara	OF	155.4	107	249	100%
148	Jameson Taillon	SP	157.1	117	237	100%
149	Ian Happ	2B, OF	159.2	108	227	100%
150	Kyle Schwarber	OF	160.7	108	212	100%
151	Brad Hand	RP	161.3	86	245	100%
152	Drew Pomeranz	SP	161.4	98	238	100%
153	Javier Baez	2B, SS	161.7	99	209	100%
154	Steven Souza	OF	161.8	115	269	100%
155	Alex Colome	RP	161.9	120	183	100%
156	Kevin Kiermaier	OF	163.5	125	292	100%
157	Evan Longoria	3B	163.6	120	210	100%
158	Jeff Samardzija	SP	165.1	120	271	100%
159	Mark Melancon	RP	167.6	143	197	100%
160	Ian Kinsler	2B	170.2	129	231	100%
161	Dylan Bundy	SP	171.8	115	297	100%
162	Mitch Haniger	OF	172.3	123	231	100%
163	Chase Anderson	SP	173.7	113	242	100%
164	Justin Bour	1B	173.9	120	215	100%
165	Josh Bell	1B	174.2	138	216	100%
166	Trevor Bauer	SP	174.3	116	231	100%
167	Ozzie Albies	2B	176.1	88	291	100%
168	Eugenio Suarez	3B	177.8	109	244	100%
169	Hector Neris	RP	179.1	139	248	100%
170	Danny Salazar	SP	179.2	137	217	95%
171	Kenta Maeda	SP	180.1	97	271	100%
172	Jacob Faria	SP	180.6	147	240	100%
173	Zack Cozart	SS	181.3	118	248	100%
174	Gio Gonzalez	SP	182.7	145	213	100%
175	Evan Gattis	C	183.4	89	262	100%
176	Taijuan Walker	SP	184.5	108	239	95%
177	Archie Bradley	RP	185.0	124	256	95%
178	Ian Desmond	1B, OF	185.8	100	277	100%
179	Charlie Morton	SP	187.1	130	212	100%
180	Jay Bruce	OF	189.1	133	249	100%
181	Brett Gardner	OF	190.4	133	293	100%
182	Bradley Zimmer	OF	190.7	105	233	100%
183	Jorge Polanco	SS	190.9	143	273	100%
184	Jeurys Familia	RP	191.3	141	273	100%
185	Kelvin Herrera	RP	192.3	128	295	100%
186	Kevin Gausman	SP	192.5	140	271	100%
187	Eric Thames	1B, OF	194.4	146	241	95%
188	Paul DeJong	2B, SS	195.6	126	254	100%
189	Sean Manaea	SP	196.2	142	279	100%
190	Andrew Miller	RP	196.7	150	245	100%
191	Welington Castillo	C	198.4	137	299	100%
192	Dexter Fowler	OF	198.9	127	271	100%
193	Blake Snell	SP	199.9	152	253	100%
194	Jason Kipnis	2B	201.8	88	289	95%
195	Patrick Corbin	SP	204.7	161	274	100%
196	Adam Duvall	OF	205.7	79	296	100%
197	Yadier Molina	C	206.9	146	243	95%
198	Wilson Ramos	C	208.1	151	276	100%
199	Odubel Herrera	OF	209.1	150	255	95%
200	Aaron Altherr	OF	210.5	141	268	100%
201	Michael Wacha	SP	210.6	142	295	95%
202	Addison Russell	SS	211.1	155	277	95%
203	Chris Davis	1B	212.0	161	260	95%
204	Andrelton Simmons	SS	212.6	129	249	95%
205	Greg Holland	RP	213.3	150	258	95%
206	Jose Martinez	1B, OF	214.9	77	291	100%
207	Mike Clevinger	SP	215.5	130	297	89%
208	Trey Mancini	1B, OF	215.9	127	297	100%
209	Scooter Gennett	2B	216.7	137	285	100%
210	Yuli Gurriel	1B	216.8	169	251	100%
211	Arodys Vizcaino	RP	217.2	138	286	95%
212	Orlando Arcia	SS	218.4	147	299	100%
213	Aaron Sanchez	SP	218.9	160	283	100%
214	Aaron Hicks	OF	219.3	165	300	100%
215	Delino DeShields	OF	220.6	169	294	95%
216	Cole Hamels	SP	221.7	147	300	95%
217	Jordan Montgomery	SP	227.0	168	286	100%
218	Blake Treinen	RP	227.4	157	282	95%
219	Jonathan Lucroy	C	228.7	135	265	89%
220	Ronald Acuna	OF	229.2	94	247	74%
221	Starlin Castro	2B	230.1	174	275	100%
222	Marcus Semien	SS	231.3	156	298	95%
223	Avisail Garcia	OF	232.9	136	294	100%
224	Brandon Belt	1B	234.5	159	252	84%
225	Carlos Gonzalez	OF	238.2	117	288	95%
226	Corey Dickerson	OF	239.8	163	271	89%
227	Max Kepler	OF	240.1	144	292	89%
228	Matt Chapman	3B	241.1	197	296	95%
229	Scott Schebler	OF	242.3	177	277	89%
230	Alex Reyes	SP	242.8	134	288	89%
231	Julio Teheran	SP	242.9	185	296	95%
232	Tim Anderson	SS	243.8	193	274	95%
233	Jackie Bradley	OF	244.7	187	275	95%
234	Yasmani Grandal	C	245.7	145	291	89%
235	Hanley Ramirez	DH	245.8	184	290	100%
236	Josh Harrison	2B, 3B	249.4	192	292	95%
237	Yonder Alonso	1B	250.4	209	299	100%
238	Austin Barnes	C	251.2	170	296	100%
239	Jose Peraza	2B, SS	251.9	172	280	79%
240	Tanner Roark	SP	252.1	208	286	95%
241	Shin-Soo Choo	OF	252.3	141	286	89%
242	Lance Lynn	SP	254.4	170	281	89%
243	David Peralta	OF	255.5	199	291	95%
244	Maikel Franco	3B	256.0	194	297	95%
245	Todd Frazier	3B	259.2	180	289	95%
246	Brandon Morrow	RP	260.5	127	235	63%
247	Jake Odorizzi	SP	261.7	204	298	53%
248	Stephen Piscotty	OF	263.1	207	300	95%
249	Blake Parker	RP	264.4	154	269	79%
250	Alex Cobb	SP	265.1	167	293	95%
251	Mark Trumbo	OF	267.2	166	296	84%
252	Willie Calhoun	OF	270.4	129	284	74%
253	Felix Hernandez	SP	270.6	160	294	74%
254	Michael Brantley	OF	272.4	162	276	74%
255	Mike Zunino	C	272.5	159	297	74%
256	Josh Reddick	OF	272.7	177	299	84%
257	Dellin Betances	RP	272.8	179	274	84%
258	Kole Calhoun	OF	276.8	190	287	84%
259	Carlos Rodon	SP	278.5	139	297	74%
260	Jimmy Nelson	SP	278.9	206	300	79%
261	Ervin Santana	SP	281.7	195	288	79%
262	Chad Green	RP	283.4	197	282	74%
263	Dinelson Lamet	SP	284.8	189	281	68%
264	David Dahl	OF	287.1	212	299	79%
265	Brian McCann	C	289.3	168	285	63%
266	Amed Rosario	SS	289.8	217	291	79%
267	Brad Brach	RP	291.3	119	246	58%
268	Cesar Hernandez	2B	292.3	172	281	68%
269	Joc Pederson	OF	294.3	179	300	58%
270	Ryon Healy	1B, 3B	299.9	201	299	68%
271	Brad Peacock	SP/RP	301.1	158	280	58%
272	Cam Bedrosian	RP	301.9	207	296	63%
273	Carl Edwards	RP	302.7	156	285	47%
274	Collin McHugh	SP	303.1	211	298	63%
275	Derek Fisher	OF	305.5	203	298	58%
276	J.A. Happ	SP	309.3	213	299	58%
277	Zach Britton	RP	310.2	191	296	63%
278	Chris Devenski	RP	310.2	238	298	68%
279	Jonathan Villar	2B	310.6	179	289	58%
280	Alex Claudio	RP	311.6	212	295	58%
281	Chris Owings	2B, SS, OF	313.8	217	298	68%
282	Tim Beckham	SS	316.8	197	294	58%
283	Shane Greene	RP	317.2	219	291	58%
284	Randall Grichuk	OF	317.8	232	300	63%
285	Eduardo Rodriguez	SP	318.2	219	300	63%
286	Luiz Gohara	SP	319.3	195	300	58%
287	Tyler Flowers	C	321.3	189	259	42%
288	Zach Davies	SP	321.8	228	298	53%
289	Steven Matz	SP	322.6	234	268	53%
290	Gleyber Torres	SS	323.7	183	288	53%
291	Ryan Mcmahon	1B	323.8	174	270	47%
292	Fernando Rodney	RP	324.1	193	274	47%
293	Michael Taylor	OF	324.4	152	292	47%
294	German Marquez	SP	324.5	215	283	47%
295	Rick Porcello	SP	324.7	219	285	53%
296	Francisco Mejia	DH	326.7	186	283	47%
297	Yasmany Tomas	OF	327.3	204	294	42%
298	Josh Hader	RP	328.6	254	300	58%
299	Kevin Pillar	OF	329.4	219	296	58%
300	Hunter Renfroe	OF	329.7	199	299	53%

Catcher Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Gary Sanchez	C	31.8	21	46	100%
2	Willson Contreras	C	68.0	45	88	100%
3	Buster Posey	C	73.6	51	94	100%
4	Salvador Perez	C	109.2	77	190	100%
5	J.T. Realmuto	C	119.3	80	208	100%
6	Evan Gattis	C	183.4	89	262	100%
7	Welington Castillo	C	198.4	137	299	100%
8	Yadier Molina	C	206.9	146	243	95%
9	Wilson Ramos	C	208.1	151	276	100%
10	Jonathan Lucroy	C	228.7	135	265	89%
11	Yasmani Grandal	C	245.7	145	291	89%
12	Austin Barnes	C	251.2	170	296	100%
13	Mike Zunino	C	272.5	159	297	74%
14	Brian McCann	C	289.3	168	285	63%
15	Tyler Flowers	C	321.3	189	259	42%
16	Robinson Chirinos	C	350.6	215	299	37%

1B Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Paul Goldschmidt	1B	7.1	3	14	100%
2	Joey Votto	1B	14.2	6	20	100%
3	Freddie Freeman	1B	19.4	12	34	100%
4	Anthony Rizzo	1B	20.1	14	24	100%
5	Cody Bellinger	1B, OF	28.6	20	62	100%
6	Jose Abreu	1B	39.8	29	55	100%
7	Rhys Hoskins	1B, OF	43.9	27	103	100%
8	Wil Myers	1B	60.5	36	88	100%
9	Edwin Encarnacion	1B	65.1	35	127	100%
10	Eric Hosmer	1B	77.0	57	115	100%
11	Justin Smoak	1B	99.3	70	143	100%
12	Miguel Cabrera	1B	105.6	63	192	100%
13	Matt Carpenter	1B	116.7	69	187	100%
14	Joey Gallo	1B, 3B	117.4	85	184	100%
15	Matt Olson	1B	130.7	65	182	100%
16	Greg Bird	1B	134.1	95	185	100%
17	Carlos Santana	1B	135.2	101	169	100%
18	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, SS, OF	148.1	117	197	100%
19	Ryan Zimmerman	1B	153.6	80	217	100%
20	Justin Bour	1B	173.9	120	215	100%
21	Josh Bell	1B	174.2	138	216	100%
22	Ian Desmond	1B, OF	185.8	100	277	100%
23	Eric Thames	1B, OF	194.4	146	241	95%
24	Chris Davis	1B	212.0	161	260	95%
25	Jose Martinez	1B, OF	214.9	77	291	100%
26	Trey Mancini	1B, OF	215.9	127	297	100%
27	Yuli Gurriel	1B	216.8	169	251	100%
28	Brandon Belt	1B	234.5	159	252	84%
29	Yonder Alonso	1B	250.4	209	299	100%
30	Ryon Healy	1B, 3B	299.9	201	299	68%
31	Ryan McMahon	1B	323.8	174	270	47%
32	Logan Morrison	1B	332.4	222	285	47%

2B Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Jose Altuve	2B	1.9	1	2	100%
2	Jose Ramirez	2B, 3B	23.7	18	37	100%
3	Brian Dozier	2B	33.5	29	40	100%
4	Dee Gordon	2B	40.3	31	67	100%
5	Daniel Murphy	2B	53.2	40	73	100%
6	Robinson Cano	2B	74.2	53	100	100%
7	Whit Merrifield	2B	75.1	39	141	100%
8	Jonathan Schoop	2B	91.9	48	146	100%
9	Rougned Odor	2B	112.4	77	200	100%
10	Chris Taylor	2B, OF	115.6	78	154	100%
11	Yoan Moncada	2B	121.4	70	166	100%
12	D.J. LeMahieu	2B	127.5	89	207	100%
13	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, SS, OF	148.1	117	197	100%
14	Eduardo Nunez	2B, 3B, OF	154.3	90	202	100%
15	Ian Happ	2B, OF	159.2	108	227	100%
16	Javier Baez	2B, SS	161.7	99	209	100%
17	Ian Kinsler	2B	170.2	129	231	100%
18	Ozzie Albies	2B	176.1	88	291	100%
19	Paul DeJong	2B, SS	195.6	126	254	100%
20	Jason Kipnis	2B	201.8	88	289	95%
21	Scooter Gennett	2B	216.7	137	285	100%
22	Starlin Castro	2B	230.1	174	275	100%
23	Josh Harrison	2B, 3B	249.4	192	292	95%
24	Jose Peraza	2B, SS	251.9	172	280	79%
25	Cesar Hernandez	2B	292.3	172	281	68%
26	Jonathan Villar	2B	310.6	179	289	58%
27	Chris Owings	2B, SS, OF	313.8	217	298	68%
28	Joe Panik	2B	330.4	222	255	42%
29	Yangervis Solarte	2B, 3B, SS	341.1	274	299	53%
30	Devon Travis	2B	345.8	233	292	37%
31	Scott Kingery	2B	351.2	259	295	42%

3B Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Nolan Arenado	3B	4.1	3	7	100%
2	Kris Bryant	3B	11.5	6	22	100%
3	Manny Machado	3B	16.3	11	24	100%
4	Jose Ramirez	2B, 3B	23.7	18	37	100%
5	Josh Donaldson	3B	26.5	11	36	100%
6	Alex Bregman	3B, SS	39.0	26	55	100%
7	Anthony Rendon	3B	41.0	30	60	100%
8	Justin Turner	3B	47.8	29	72	100%
9	Jake Lamb	3B	101.9	63	175	95%
10	Travis Shaw	3B	102.6	72	195	100%
11	Kyle Seager	3B	103.6	64	165	100%
12	Miguel Sano	3B	105.3	59	166	100%
13	Joey Gallo	1B, 3B	117.4	85	184	100%
14	Rafael Devers	3B	122.1	79	184	100%
15	Adrian Beltre	3B	123.9	59	223	100%
16	Mike Moustakas	3B	133.3	87	270	100%
17	Nick Castellanos	3B	136.9	96	176	100%
18	Eduardo Nunez	2B, 3B, OF	154.3	90	202	100%
19	Evan Longoria	3B	163.6	120	210	100%
20	Eugenio Suarez	3B	177.8	109	244	100%
21	Matt Chapman	3B	241.1	197	296	95%
22	Josh Harrison	2B, 3B	249.4	192	292	95%
23	Maikel Franco	3B	256.0	194	297	95%
24	Todd Frazier	3B	259.2	180	289	95%
25	Ryon Healy	1B, 3B	299.9	201	299	68%
26	Yangervis Solarte	2B, 3B, SS	341.1	274	299	53%
27	Jedd Gyorko	3B	354.6	245	294	37%
28	Eduardo Escobar	3B	355.5	237	295	37%

SS Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Trea Turner	SS	6.3	3	14	100%
2	Carlos Correa	SS	9.9	3	15	100%
3	Francisco Lindor	SS	16.5	8	24	100%
4	Corey Seager	SS	26.6	15	42	100%
5	Alex Bregman	3B, SS	39.0	26	55	100%
6	Elvis Andrus	SS	62.6	41	80	100%
7	Jean Segura	SS	73.8	52	104	100%
8	Xander Bogaerts	SS	81.4	52	108	100%
9	Didi Gregorius	SS	143.2	86	187	100%
10	Trevor Story	SS	147.5	91	217	100%
11	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, SS, OF	148.1	117	197	100%
12	Javier Baez	2B, SS	161.7	99	209	100%
13	Zack Cozart	SS	181.3	118	248	100%
14	Jorge Polanco	SS	190.9	143	273	100%
15	Paul DeJong	2B, SS	195.6	126	254	100%
16	Addison Russell	SS	211.1	155	277	95%
17	Andrelton Simmons	SS	212.6	129	249	95%
18	Orlando Arcia	SS	218.4	147	299	100%
19	Marcus Semien	SS	231.3	156	298	95%
20	Tim Anderson	SS	243.8	193	274	95%
21	Jose Peraza	2B, SS	251.9	172	280	79%
22	Amed Rosario	SS	289.8	217	291	79%
23	Chris Owings	2B, SS, OF	313.8	217	298	68%
24	Tim Beckham	SS	316.8	197	294	58%
25	Gleyber Torres	SS	323.7	183	288	53%
26	Dansby Swanson	SS	335.4	231	294	47%

OF Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Mike Trout	OF	1.1	1	2	100%
2	Mookie Betts	OF	5.9	3	10	100%
3	Bryce Harper	OF	6.3	3	13	100%
4	Charlie Blackmon	OF	9.6	3	20	100%
5	Giancarlo Stanton	OF	9.6	6	24	100%
6	Aaron Judge	OF	19.9	12	30	100%
7	J.D. Martinez	OF	22.9	17	31	100%
8	George Springer	OF	25.5	22	35	100%
9	Cody Bellinger	1B, OF	28.6	20	62	100%
10	Rhys Hoskins	1B, OF	43.9	27	103	100%
11	Christian Yelich	OF	45.4	38	64	100%
12	Justin Upton	OF	46.1	30	73	100%
13	Marcell Ozuna	OF	46.5	32	74	100%
14	Andrew Benintendi	OF	50.2	40	76	100%
15	Starling Marte	OF	58.2	36	95	100%
16	Byron Buxton	OF	61.8	43	85	100%
17	Tommy Pham	OF	63.9	53	143	100%
18	Yoenis Cespedes	OF	74.6	60	97	100%
19	A.J. Pollock	OF	74.7	42	101	100%
20	Andrew McCutchen	OF	82.3	64	105	100%
21	Lorenzo Cain	OF	82.7	60	104	100%
22	Billy Hamilton	OF	83.8	61	182	100%
23	Domingo Santana	OF	85.5	59	138	100%
24	Khris Davis	OF	88.6	46	166	100%
25	Ryan Braun	OF	92.9	74	138	100%
26	Yasiel Puig	OF	97.9	57	163	100%
27	Ender Inciarte	OF	111.1	83	152	100%
28	Adam Eaton	OF	112.5	90	166	100%
29	Chris Taylor	2B, OF	115.6	78	154	100%
30	Gregory Polanco	OF	134.7	100	171	100%
31	Eddie Rosario	OF	141.2	66	223	100%
32	Manuel Margot	OF	142.4	105	256	100%
33	Michael Conforto	OF	142.8	85	191	100%
34	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, SS, OF	148.1	117	197	100%
35	Adam Jones	OF	152.5	90	219	100%
36	Eduardo Nunez	2B, 3B, OF	154.3	90	202	100%
37	Nomar Mazara	OF	155.4	107	249	100%
38	Ian Happ	2B, OF	159.2	108	227	100%
39	Kyle Schwarber	OF	160.7	108	212	100%
40	Steven Souza	OF	161.8	115	269	100%
41	Kevin Kiermaier	OF	163.5	125	292	100%
42	Mitch Haniger	OF	172.3	123	231	100%
43	Ian Desmond	1B, OF	185.8	100	277	100%
44	Jay Bruce	OF	189.1	133	249	100%
45	Brett Gardner	OF	190.4	133	293	100%
46	Bradley Zimmer	OF	190.7	105	233	100%
47	Eric Thames	1B, OF	194.4	146	241	95%
48	Dexter Fowler	OF	198.9	127	271	100%
49	Adam Duvall	OF	205.7	79	296	100%
50	Odubel Herrera	OF	209.1	150	255	95%
51	Aaron Altherr	OF	210.5	141	268	100%
52	Jose Martinez	1B, OF	214.9	77	291	100%
53	Trey Mancini	1B, OF	215.9	127	297	100%
54	Aaron Hicks	OF	219.3	165	300	100%
55	Delino DeShields	OF	220.6	169	294	95%
56	Ronald Acuna	OF	229.2	94	247	74%
57	Avisail Garcia	OF	232.9	136	294	100%
58	Carlos Gonzalez	OF	238.2	117	288	95%
59	Corey Dickerson	OF	239.8	163	271	89%
60	Max Kepler	OF	240.1	144	292	89%
61	Scott Schebler	OF	242.3	177	277	89%
62	Jackie Bradley	OF	244.7	187	275	95%
63	Shin-Soo Choo	OF	252.3	141	286	89%
64	David Peralta	OF	255.5	199	291	95%
65	Stephen Piscotty	OF	263.1	207	300	95%
66	Mark Trumbo	OF	267.2	166	296	84%
67	Willie Calhoun	OF	270.4	129	284	74%
68	Michael Brantley	OF	272.4	162	276	74%
69	Josh Reddick	OF	272.7	177	299	84%
70	Kole Calhoun	OF	276.8	190	287	84%
71	David Dahl	OF	287.1	212	299	79%
72	Joc Pederson	OF	294.3	179	300	58%
73	Derek Fisher	OF	305.5	203	298	58%
74	Chris Owings	2B, SS, OF	313.8	217	298	68%
75	Randall Grichuk	OF	317.8	232	300	63%
76	Michael Taylor	OF	324.4	152	292	47%
77	Yasmany Tomas	OF	327.3	204	294	42%
78	Kevin Pillar	OF	329.4	219	296	58%
79	Hunter Renfroe	OF	329.7	199	299	53%
80	Lewis Brinson	OF	336.7	169	299	47%
81	Matt Kemp	OF	336.8	229	290	47%
82	Nick Williams	OF	339.6	220	285	42%
83	Alex Dickerson	OF	342.4	223	287	37%

SP Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Clayton Kershaw	SP	9.8	5	17	100%
2	Max Scherzer	SP	15.3	11	20	100%
3	Chris Sale	SP	16.1	12	21	100%
4	Corey Kluber	SP	17.8	15	22	100%
5	Stephen Strasburg	SP	27.4	22	35	100%
6	Noah Syndergaard	SP	28.7	23	34	100%
7	Madison Bumgarner	SP	29.8	25	51	100%
8	Luis Severino	SP	33.8	25	52	100%
9	Jacob deGrom	SP	34.2	26	40	100%
10	Zack Greinke	SP	40.1	26	57	100%
11	Carlos Carrasco	SP	44.9	36	64	100%
12	Yu Darvish	SP	46.0	23	55	100%
13	Carlos Martinez	SP	52.8	38	76	100%
14	Justin Verlander	SP	54.6	38	90	100%
15	Aaron Nola	SP	56.1	39	78	100%
16	James Paxton	SP	60.0	46	86	100%
17	Chris Archer	SP	60.3	46	76	100%
18	Robbie Ray	SP	66.4	43	127	100%
19	Dallas Keuchel	SP	67.1	49	98	100%
20	Gerrit Cole	SP	82.5	42	130	100%
21	Jose Quintana	SP	82.8	62	103	100%
22	Masahiro Tanaka	SP	84.5	67	116	100%
23	Shohei Ohtani	SP	88.6	58	155	100%
24	David Price	SP	89.8	47	151	100%
25	Luis Castillo	SP	91.6	66	110	100%
26	Jake Arrieta	SP	94.5	56	117	100%
27	Lance McCullers	SP	97.3	43	151	100%
28	Alex Wood	SP	98.6	63	155	100%
29	Zack Godley	SP	101.7	65	136	100%
30	Marcus Stroman	SP	103.7	39	167	100%
31	Sonny Gray	SP	107.5	52	175	100%
32	Kyle Hendricks	SP	117.3	89	176	100%
33	Jose Berrios	SP	121.8	83	179	100%
34	Luke Weaver	SP	123.4	86	169	100%
35	Michael Fulmer	SP	124.2	92	173	100%
36	Jon Lester	SP	126.8	102	157	100%
37	Jon Gray	SP	132.8	78	179	100%
38	Danny Duffy	SP	139.7	102	175	100%
39	Johnny Cueto	SP	140.7	100	252	100%
40	Garrett Richards	SP	153.7	124	194	100%
41	Rich Hill	SP	154.7	83	254	100%
42	Jameson Taillon	SP	157.1	117	237	100%
43	Drew Pomeranz	SP	161.4	98	238	100%
44	Jeff Samardzija	SP	165.1	120	271	100%
45	Dylan Bundy	SP	171.8	115	297	100%
46	Chase Anderson	SP	173.7	113	242	100%
47	Trevor Bauer	SP	174.3	116	231	100%
48	Danny Salazar	SP	179.2	137	217	95%
49	Kenta Maeda	SP	180.1	97	271	100%
50	Jacob Faria	SP	180.6	147	240	100%
51	Gio Gonzalez	SP	182.7	145	213	100%
52	Taijuan Walker	SP	184.5	108	239	95%
53	Charlie Morton	SP	187.1	130	212	100%
54	Kevin Gausman	SP	192.5	140	271	100%
55	Sean Manaea	SP	196.2	142	279	100%
56	Blake Snell	SP	199.9	152	253	100%
57	Patrick Corbin	SP	204.7	161	274	100%
58	Michael Wacha	SP	210.6	142	295	95%
59	Mike Clevinger	SP	215.5	130	297	89%
60	Aaron Sanchez	SP	218.9	160	283	100%
61	Cole Hamels	SP	221.7	147	300	95%
62	Jordan Montgomery	SP	227.0	168	286	100%
63	Alex Reyes	SP	242.8	134	288	89%
64	Julio Teheran	SP	242.9	185	296	95%
65	Tanner Roark	SP	252.1	208	286	95%
66	Lance Lynn	SP	254.4	170	281	89%
67	Jake Odorizzi	SP	261.7	204	298	53%
68	Alex Cobb	SP	265.1	167	293	95%
69	Felix Hernandez	SP	270.6	160	294	74%
70	Carlos Rodon	SP	278.5	139	297	74%
71	Jimmy Nelson	SP	278.9	206	300	79%
72	Ervin Santana	SP	281.7	195	288	79%
73	Dinelson Lamet	SP	284.8	189	281	68%
74	Brad Peacock	SP/RP	301.1	158	280	58%
74	Collin McHugh	SP	303.1	211	298	63%
75	J.A. Happ	SP	309.3	213	299	58%
76	Eduardo Rodriguez	SP	318.2	219	300	63%
77	Luiz Gohara	SP	319.3	195	300	58%
78	Zach Davies	SP	321.8	228	298	53%
79	Steven Matz	SP	322.6	234	268	53%
80	German Marquez	SP	324.5	215	283	47%
81	Rick Porcello	SP	324.7	219	285	53%
82	Lucas Giolito	SP	331.3	205	289	47%
83	Mike Foltynewicz	SP	337.7	220	277	37%
84	Miles Mikolas	SP	340.8	210	292	42%
85	Sean Newcomb	SP	347.7	263	299	47%
86	Ivan Nova	SP	350.5	257	293	42%
87	Joe Biagini	SP, RP	352.8	237	298	37%
88	Joe Musgrove	SP, RP	354.7	232	300	37%

RP Rankings

Ranking	Name	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Kenley Jansen	RP	55.1	40	71	100%
2	Craig Kimbrel	RP	62.4	44	81	100%
3	Corey Knebel	RP	87.1	62	116	100%
4	Aroldis Chapman	RP	88.3	63	123	100%
5	Roberto Osuna	RP	89.7	75	119	100%
6	Felipe Rivero	RP	94.5	71	127	100%
7	Ken Giles	RP	112.1	67	157	100%
8	Edwin Diaz	RP	112.4	82	135	100%
9	Cody Allen	RP	120.6	93	161	100%
10	Wade Davis	RP	121.2	72	150	100%
11	Raisel Iglesias	RP	125.5	89	148	100%
12	Sean Doolittle	RP	151.9	101	280	100%
13	Brad Hand	RP	161.3	86	245	100%
14	Alex Colome	RP	161.9	120	183	100%
15	Mark Melancon	RP	167.6	143	197	100%
16	Hector Neris	RP	179.1	139	248	100%
17	Archie Bradley	RP	185.0	124	256	95%
18	Jeurys Familia	RP	191.3	141	273	100%
19	Kelvin Herrera	RP	192.3	128	295	100%
20	Andrew Miller	RP	196.7	150	245	100%
21	Greg Holland	RP	213.3	150	258	95%
22	Arodys Vizcaino	RP	217.2	138	286	95%
23	Blake Treinen	RP	227.4	157	282	95%
24	Brandon Morrow	RP	260.5	127	235	63%
25	Blake Parker	RP	264.4	154	269	79%
26	Dellin Betances	RP	272.8	179	274	84%
27	Chad Green	RP	283.4	197	282	74%
28	Brad Brach	RP	291.3	119	246	58%
29	Brad Peacock	SP/RP	301.1	158	280	58%
30	Cam Bedrosian	RP	301.9	207	296	63%
31	Carl Edwards	RP	302.7	156	285	47%
32	Zach Britton	RP	310.2	191	296	63%
33	Chris Devenski	RP	310.2	238	298	68%
34	Alex Claudio	RP	311.6	212	295	58%
35	Shane Greene	RP	317.2	219	291	58%
36	Fernando Rodney	RP	324.1	193	274	47%
37	Josh Hader	RP	328.6	254	300	58%
38	Kyle Barraclough	RP	330.5	238	290	53%
39	Luke Gregerson	RP	346.3	209	294	37%
40	David Robertson	RP	352.5	253	291	37%
41	Joe Biagini	SP, RP	352.8	237	298	37%
42	Joe Musgrove	SP, RP	354.7	232	300	37%

Notes

• Players who weren’t ranked on a list received a ranking of 400 for the purpose of creating the consensus ranking.
• Brandon Morrow was not included in the template file that all the writers received (by accident). This is why he was not ranked on 7 lists. His consensus ranking among the 12 writers that ranked him was 179, which would put him around relievers Hector Neris and Archie Bradley.
• Buster Posey was not included in the 1B rankings and is the only player who wasn’t included in all of his eligible positions. This is because no one is drafting Posey to play first base.
• Similarly, Anthony Rizzo was not included in the 2B rankings because many leagues do not have him eligible to play there. He would be the #2 second basemen, just ahead of Jose Ramirez.
• These lists were created solely for the 2018 season. Be sure to take that into account if you play in any type of keeper or dynasty league.
• Writers who contributed (in alphabetical order): Alex Isherwood, Andrew Gould, Andrew Todd-Smith, Andy Patton, Austin Bristow, Ben Palmer, Ben Pernick, Grayson Blazek, Jake Bridges, Jay Dunbar, Jonathan Metzelaar, KV Singh, Kyle Bishop, Mark Weston, Max Posner, Michael Grennell, Myles Nelson, Nick Pollack, and Tim Acree.